When a Supreme Court justice retires, President Bartlet has a golden opportunity to impact the court's composition by nominating a favorite judge but when further study reveals the ... See full summary »



(created by), (teleplay by) | 3 more credits »

Watch Now

From $1.99 (SD) on Amazon Video



1 video »


Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Congressman Peter Lillienfield
Justice Joseph Crouch
Judge Peyton Cabot Harrison III


When a Supreme Court justice retires, President Bartlet has a golden opportunity to impact the court's composition by nominating a favorite judge but when further study reveals the candidate's conflicting ideology, the President might change his mind and opt for another judge. In addition, a headline seeking congressman on the House Government Oversight Committee accuses the White House staff of substance abuse -- a dicey issue for one important member. Written by Jackson corneille

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis







Release Date:

24 November 1999 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


During Congressman Lillienfield's press conference, he mentions some names of former White House staffers. One name included was Rumsfeld, who had staffed for Presidents Nixon and Ford prior to this episode. He was later named to the cabinet, again, under President George W. Bush. See more »


While grilling Judge Harrison in the Oval Office, Sam points out the Third, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments all contain points of privacy in the Bill of Rights. Judge Harrison states that because the framers of the Constitution picked those specific points, they had no intention of including privacy as a right. Everyone seems to have forgotten the Ninth Amendment, which reads: "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." See more »


Josh Lyman: [after a press conference that claimed 1 out of 3 White House staffers takes drugs] Five White House staffers in the room... I would like to say to the 1.6 of you who are stoned right now that it's time to share.
See more »


References Masterpiece Classic (1971) See more »


West Wing Main Title
Written by W.G. Snuffy Walden
Performed by Pete Anthony
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Law, politics and goldfish: three reasons to love this episode
21 September 2009 | by (Canada) – See all my reviews

For those of us hoping constitutional interpretation of the law is a neutral, objective undertaking, it may be discouraging to realize there's a lot of politics in it. That's partly why judges often disagree with each other and write dissents; their politics are different. This episode, which is about President Bartlet's opportunity to nominate a Supreme Court justice, is aware of that. Bartlet's first choice for the job becomes less appealing when the White House learns this judge isn't committed to privacy rights. The retiring Supreme Court justice is a liberal and disappointed by Bartlet's moderate politics and his candidate.

Disagreement about whether Bartlet falls short of greatness, as the retiring justice argues, makes for good drama; the two men compare Bartlet to Harry Truman. The issue of privacy rights is good drama too since it deals with a fundamental freedom that is still hotly debated. And then there's Leo, who's a great character. We learn that in addition to alcoholism he may have once been hooked on drugs; the president and staff are still willing to support him, however. They should. Leo's a great man.

An amusing subplot has CJ getting a goldfish after a miscommunication. Because of this episode, I named one of my own pet goldfish CJ. CJ the fish didn't last long, I'm afraid. Altogether, this is yet another fine episode from The West Wing's first season.

9 of 9 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
What's the big deal? ashleyjharrison
How did Andy get pregnant? jennamaria-09155
Sam Seaborn rolaca
Toby was never more right than in the ep "17 People". MyNameIsOliverQueen
Are there any episodes you skip? Whedonbuff
Doesn't really matter but just saying... pmac7902
Discuss The Short List (1999) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: