(TV Series)

(1977)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Decent episode featuring both a murder mystery and a social issue
rayoflite2411 August 2015
Valleyview begins with an elderly man dying following an injection by an unidentifiable staff member of the Valleyview nursing facility. The grandson of the deceased, David Phillips (Ed Begley, Jr.), later shows up at the coroner lab to request that Quincy (Jack Klugman) perform an autopsy as he does not believe the cause of death was a coronary as reported by the facility. Quincy determines that the cause of death listed was inaccurate, but he cannot pinpoint the exact cause of death and also learns that the deceased had pancreatic cancer. His suspicions are heightened when a young girl with mental health issues also dies very unexpectedly, leading him to believe there might be a mercy killer among the staff of Valleyview.

This is a decent Season 2 episode of Quincy which features an interesting murder mystery with multiple victims and several suspects. I was pleased to see that the producers made the focus of this episode a murder mystery where the crimes committed are mercy killings rather than making this solely an episode focused on the social issue with no crime or investigation component. This was the right way to do it in my opinion and I wish all of the episodes featuring a social problem were written in this manner. There are some good guest stars and the drama continues right up to the climactic conclusion.

I usually never comment on the appearances of the actors in these shows here, but I found Carolyn Jones' hairdo in this episode to be so bizarre and unflattering that I have to mention it as it was a constant distraction throughout which I could not stop staring at. It is cut so short that it makes her look more masculine than her male co-stars who were all sporting longer locks which were the style of the time (remember this was 1977). It also looked as if a child took a pair of scissors to her bangs which were all zig-zagged and crooked. I don't know if it was one of the hairstylists of the show that was responsible for this chopped mess or she had it done on her own, but whoever it was should have been fired and had their cosmetology license pulled!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good Quincy murder mystery.
poolandrews3 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Valleyview starts as Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) is asked to perform a private autopsy on seventy six year old Howard Phillips by his Grandson David (Ed Begley Jr.), the official cause of death is a heart attack but David is sure that was not the case & that the Doctor's at Valleyview Sanitarium are hiding something. After the autopsy Quincy is puzzled, he has no idea how Howard died & it certainly wasn't from a heart attack although Quincy discovers Howard was suffering from prostate cancer. Then another body, that of mentally retarded teenager Anne, is brought in on a tip-off & again Quincy can find no cause of death. Quincy then thinks that there may be a mercy killer at Valleyview murdering terminally ill patients but no-one will believe him & without any evidence he has nowhere to go...

Episode 12 from season 2 this Quincy story was directed by Ronald Satlof & is a very entertaining murder mystery with which to pass fifty odd minutes. Here the sensitive & emotive issue of euthanasia & mercy killing is brought up but while in later seasons of Quincy this issue would have been explored much deeper, dominated proceedings & been the moral issue of the week here in Valleyview it is merely used as a backdrop & motive for multiple murder that Quincy has to use his medical knowledge & skills to solve & as such doesn't go to much into the moral & social issues, implications & arguments surrounding the delicate topic which is fine with me since I much prefer the murder mystery themed Quincy episodes than the overly heavy handed moralistic ones. Valleyview is solid throughout, there's a steady stream of murder victims, there's a strong mystery element, the final outcome isn't too obvious & will probably keep you guessing until the end, there's the scenes where Quincy comes up against & fights bureaucracy, there's the scenes where no-one will believe Quincy & his ideas & there's that trademark Quincy humour. Pretty much all any Quincy fan would want from an episode really.

There's nothing that is particularly memorable in this episode, it's well made but somewhat flat & a bit bland. Have you ever noticed the production team use the same still shot of Quincy's car parked outside Danny's? I'm sure it's just a single stock photograph that they use as a quick establishing shot to show that Quincy is at Danny's in the same way all the exterior shot's of Quincy's building look exactly the same! The acting is alright here so there's no problems on that front, TV & Hollywood veteran Ed Begley Jr. makes his first of three Quincy guest appearances & would next feature in the excellent No Way to Treat a Body (1978) during season four while Carolyn Jones made this the same year she starred in Tobe Hooper's one time 'video nasty' here in the UK the sleazy killer man eating Crocodile flick Eaten Alive (1977).

Valleyview is a good solid early Quincy murder mystery that has a hint of a moral message but thankfully doesn't let it overshadow or dominate the mystery crime elements.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Giant plot hole ruins it Warning: Spoilers
When the nurse is a victim, it's determined that the syringe used to kill her was injected under her fingernail. Now in order for the killer to have done this, he would have had to have knocked her out first which would've showed signs of trauma during the autopsy.

We saw the nurse enter a room with the killer right behind and the next shot was of the next morning. We conveniently don't get to see just how he accomplished this feat of injecting the syringe into her fingernail.

The nurse would have immediately put up a struggle so it would have been near impossible to get the syringe into her fingernail unless he asked her to give him her hand and not to move it.

So the only plausible way for this to have occurred was to knock her unconscious and then inject the syringe, but knocking her out would have shown signs of trauma in the autopsy. It's too giant a plot hole to ignore.
14 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Oooh, this is a good one.
planktonrules17 March 2013
At a local sanitarium, an old man dies unexpectedly from an apparent heart attack. The man's grandson (Ed Begley Jr.) requests an autopsy and Quincy determines that the death was NOT from a heart attack but he can't find an exact cause. A bit later, a young lady from the same sanitarium dies and it's called a heart attack as well--but Quincy sees this as way too coincidental but again he can't find a cause. Astin pushes Quincy to give up and stop making irresponsible allegations (which he had been doing). But, when a third death soon occurs, it's obvious to anyone that this is NOT a series of coincidences. But how are people dying and who is doing it?!

This episode was among the best of the second season. Part of it is that several 'angels of death' (such as Donald Harvey) have been caught killing patients in the places where they work. Part of it is because it's very intelligently written and interesting. In other words, Quincy comes off as a reasonable person--not a social worker/cop rolled up into one. His worries about the rash of unexplained deaths were reasonable and made for a very tight story. I also liked the final attempted murder--it was, in a very dark way, kind of funny. All in all, well worth your time.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
There's quite a star studded guest cast this week....
AlsExGal10 February 2024
... and that cast includes Jason Evers of "The Brain That Wouldn't Die", Robert Webber who was one of the Twelve Angry Men along with Jack Klugman, Carolyn Jones, and Ed Begley Jr. As he was just getting started at age 27.

An old man dies of what the hospital he is staying in says is a coronary, but his grandson (Ed Begley Jr) doesn't buy it. He pays the city the fee to do an autopsy and Quincy cannot determine cause of death, but can definitely say it was not a coronary. Then a few days later a very mentally ill patient in the same hospital dies suddenly in the night. Quincy's autopsy again cannot find the cause of death. Quincy thinks that he has a mercy killer on the loose when the exact same hospital reports a nurse found dead. Her autopsy turns out like the other two - cause of death unknown.

Things are made more complex when the doctor who runs the sanitarium admits that he is in favor of euthanasia. Could he be the perpetrator? Watch and find out.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
12 angry men reunion
clj7on5 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
season 2 episode Valley view. suddenly realized that this episode contains connection to 3 actors from the classic 12 angry men. Jack Klugman was juror #5 Robert Webber was juror #12 and Ed Begley Jr is the son of Juror #10

Actors with history usually make for good chemistry. wonder if Jack agreed to help Ed Begly Jr as a favor to his dad.

Quincy was cutting edge for the time and the story lines were sometimes "Ripped from the headlines". Quincy was a profiler and a one man CSI team. Jack Klugman was as good a comedic actor as he was a dramatic actor
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed