(TV Series)

(1979)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Excellent episode
rayoflite243 October 2015
Eye of the Needle begins with Helen Burnett (Sally Kemp) pulling off the road in agonizing pain and attempting to call her doctor from a phone booth. A derelict drifter (Anthony James) seeing she is well-dressed and driving a Mercedes approaches first offering to help, but then steals her purse and leaves her there. Helen manages to drive herself home, but as she pulls into the garage and closes the door with a remote she loses consciousness with the car still running. The next morning she is found dead and Quincy (Jack Klugman) conducts the autopsy concluding that Helen died of carbon monoxide poisoning after being rendered unconscious by a ruptured perforated ulcer for which she should have been hospitalized. He further discovers that her doctor was Barrie Stoddard (Frances Lee McCain), a physician who promotes holistic medicine and Quincy has been interested in romantically. A furious Quincy confronts Dr. Stoddard asking how she could let this happen, but when she presents evidence that Helen's ulcer had drastically decreased only days before it becomes clear that there is more to this death and further investigation is necessary. Meanwhile, Helen's husband files a multi-million dollar malpractice lawsuit against Dr. Stoddard placing her career in jeopardy.

I found this to be an excellent Quincy episode which has everything including a complex death, an intriguing mystery with plenty of twists and turns, intense debate over a controversial method of care and good guest stars who deliver convincing performances. I thought all of the regular players were great in this one as well and very true to their characters which we don't always see consistently throughout the series. Right from the opening scenes I was drawn into the plot as you can't help but feel bad for this poor woman who was victimized, and the rest of the story managed to keep my interest throughout.

My only criticism of this episode is the scene where Quincy tells Monohan (Garry Walberg) to reward the thief with a steak dinner after he told them where he dumped the contents of the purse. While he did provide a critical piece of information, this doesn't change the fact that he was still a low life criminal who was partially responsible for Helen's death as he saw she was in severe distress and robbed her instead of calling for help or driving her to the hospital. He should have earned additional charges against him for that rather than a high end meal!

Aside from that, this is a very entertaining and interesting Season 4 Finale episode which I highly recommend viewing!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent Quincy episode.
poolandrews31 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: The Eye of the Needle starts with Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) & his boss Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) attending a lecture about holistic medicine by Dr. Barri Stodder (Frances Lee McCain) who is a practitioner of the controversial technique. The next morning & Quincy is outraged to find that the body of Helen Burnett (Sally Kemp) has ended up on his autopsy table after an ulcer burst killing her, Quincy is shocked that the ulcer was in such an advanced & untreated state. After learning that Dr. Stodder treated Helen with naturalistic techniques rather than proved medical ones Quincy talks to her & becomes convinced that she was not responsible for the death, Quincy then has to investigate Helen's death further in order to find out what killed her before Dr. Stodder's holistic clinic is closed down for good...

Episode 23 from season 4 this Quincy story was directed by Ronald Satlof & one can't help but notice & comment on the similarities between The Eye of the Needle & another Quincy episode from season four Death by Good Intentions since they are virtually the same in both plot & resolution. Like in Death by Good Intentions here Quincy has to go back & examine a case to uncover the truth in order to save a friends career which is put in jeopardy when one their patients die & they are blamed for it, Quincy uses his medical expertise to prove that they weren't responsible & that someone committed murder. It's actually quite striking how similar the two episodes are right down to an antagonistic fellow professional who wants to see the said Doctor in question ruined & an expensive lawsuit issued by the relatives of the deceased. So in essence they are pretty much the same & in that regard they are both perfectly entertaining episodes that have a moral message put to the viewer from both sides (although it's made clear which side 'we' should be on) for the first half & more of a murder mystery during the second half as Quincy does what he does best. Not a bad episode at all.

This is yet another unremarkable episode that is functional but not much to look at, the one thing that does stick out in The Eye of the Needle is that it must feature the tallest mugger in history! The guy who plays the mugger is huge! Just look at how long his legs are in full length shots.

The Eye of the Needle is a perfectly entertaining episode of Quincy that mixes the usual moral messages & murder mysteries well enough, I liked it. It's not a classic episode but I liked it.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Sometimes, Quincy is just annoying!
planktonrules21 April 2013
This episode of "Quincy" begins with a woman in some sort of physical distress trying to get some help. Unfortunately, the guy she finds is just some thief--who steals her purse and leaves her in agony. Soon, she is discovered...dead. They think it's due to carbon monoxide poisoning, but it turns out she died from a perforated ulcer--something you'd rarely die from in this day and age. So, without looking into the facts, Quincy runs about half-cocked making wild accusations against the dead lady's doctor. These wild accusations appear to lead to the surviving husband filing suit against this doctor--and it's a great case of Quincy opening his big, fat mouth! Later, when Quincy finds out that a LADY doctor is the attending physician (one that he was really lusting after earlier in the episode), Quincy changes his tone completely--and spends the rest of the film trying to prove the doctor was innocent!! This hypocrisy and sexism really make it hard to like Quincy in this one--and I am surprised that his part was written this way. Because he was so inconsistent and never apologized for creating a lynch-mob mentality, I found this one a less than stellar episode. The writing just wasn't up to snuff here.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Too huge a flaw not to notice
LaverneandShirleysucks13 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy is investigating a woman who died as a result of a perforated ulcer. Halfway through the episode he's at the police station questioning a derelict who took the woman's purse as she was dying.

During questioning Quincy asks if there were any pills besides aspirin in her purse, to try and find out if anything she took caused her death, which he denies. A few moments later though he complains that he's having stomach pains but Quincy just sits there and ignores it.

Hello?!....The woman died of a stomach ulcer, and this derelict who took her purse is now complaining of STOMACH PAINS! Quincy just sits there deep in thought but doesn't make the obvious connection!! Give me a break! He's not that stupid. No one is.

It's PAINFUL to watch because anyone with an ounce of common sense, especially a doctor would want this guy tested immediately to check the source of those stomach pains. And what may be in his system and match it with the woman.

Instead the derelict is sent on his merry way until later in the episode the derelict winds up in a clinic because of the stomach pains and finally...FINALLY the light bulb goes off and the connection is made LOL. So dumb!

It makes Quincy look like a complete buffoon for ignoring the derelicts stomach complaints and it's incredibly bad writing, because Quincy would have immediately made the connection and asked the derelict how long he's had those stomach pains. It's too big a flaw and completely ruins the entire episode. 1 star for the idiocy of the writing.
14 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed