Cynthia Perkins' musician boyfriend Donald Hobart is charged with killing his sponsor in a small town. Perry and Paul there on other business decide to investigate. Based on their findings he is freed and Cynthia is charged instead.



(characters created by),

On Disc

at Amazon


Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Will Hutchins ...
Donald Hobart
Sheriff Moose Dalton
Cynthia Perkins
Elaine Bayler
Lloyd Gough ...
Richard Bayler
Aaron Chambers (as Clint Sundberg)
Ed Kesko
Dee Pollock ...
Howard Bayler
Connie Gilchrist ...
Blair Davies ...
C. A. Woodmire
William Keene ...
Judge Seymour
Walter Stocker ...
Charlie Horgan


On his way to a few days of fishing with Paul Drake, Perry Mason stops off to get his client Richard Bayler to sign some legal papers. They arrive to learn that Bayler's wife Elaine was shot while she was sitting in her car. Bayler has already decided who the guilty party is: Donald Hobart, an aspiring songwriter whom Elaine was supporting financially. There was more than just a hint of jealousy on Bayler's part but according to Hobart's girlfriend Cynthia Perkins, there was nothing going on between them. Perry upset at Bayler's attempt to railroad Hobart returns Bayler's retainer. Paul investigates the murder scene running into the very helpful local, Aaron Chambers. However, Chambers turns out to be the local forensics expert for the sheriff's department. Based on the evidence the two of them find, Hobart is released and his girlfriend Cynthia is arrested for the murder. With Cynthia accused of the murder, Perry agrees to defend her. Written by garykmcd

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Plot Keywords:

ford mustang | See All (1) »


Crime | Drama | Mystery





Release Date:

20 February 1966 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs



Sound Mix:

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

The ending was rushed- but still a good show.
31 January 2013 | by (United States) – See all my reviews

On Perry's way on a fishing trip, Paul and he drive over to Mr Richard Bayler's house so that he can sign some legal papers. Upon arriving they have found out that Bayler's wife, Elaine, had been shot and killed the night before and they have a young man named Donald Hobart in custody.

Donald, a musician, had been living in a cottage owned by the Baylers while he wrote songs for Ms Bayler. While Donald and his girlfriend, Cynthia Perkins, were at the cottage, Ms Bayler comes walking in and demands that Donald go with her. She has a letter that is blackmailing her saying that Ms Bayler and Donald was having an affair. A note tells her to leave money in a park so Elaine gets Donald to deliver the money. When Donald gets out to place the money, Elaine is shot and killed. Donald is arrested.

In this small community, Mr Bayler controls nearly all aspects of the town. With nearly all lawyers refusing to go against Bayler, Perry is asked to defend Dan. When Mr Bayler finds out that Perry is asked to defend the accused- Bayler demands Perry to leave or he will not be his lawyer anymore. Perry advises that that he will return Mr Bayler's retainer because no one will order him about.

But when evidence is gathered by the sheriff department, Cynthia Perkins will be charged with the murder and Perry will defend her in court.

In rushed courtroom scenes. Perry will question the witnesses until a surprising result develops. Someone that appears to be innocent will make a terrible mistake and will lead to Perry getting the charges of murder against Cynthia dripped.

The show was top notch until we get to the courtroom. I guess they spent so much time with the story that when the courtroom scenes came it had to be rushed to get the result in the allotted time. Too bad- It finished poorly after such a great start. But it was a nice watch as Perry has some good lines in the episode.

7 of 8 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
30 min episode? wesperkins
Smoking wesperkins
Does Lt. Tragg just follow Perry around? Clintessence
If they made a new Perry Mason feature film kbla-61543
Why don't topics bump up to the top of this message board? kbla-61543
Does Hamilton Burger never win a case ever?? bunnellius
Discuss The Case of the Scarlet Scandal (1966) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: