Corey overhears a whispered conversation in a bath house that leads him to believe "The Butcher of Bennington" is in town. Twelve people died when they refused to hand over a confederate soldier during the war, who was Corey. The man was being blackmailed by a soldier. Later, the soldier, who was fatally stabbed, collapses in Corey's arms. The owner of the bath house supposedly hangs himself. Corey investigates and eliminates suspects. The main suspect has a paralyzed arm and is a friend of Jamal's.