After Lucas crowns another good game with the winning point, Nathan switches to plan B, inviting him to a party at his dad's luxurious beach house where he cleverly humiliates him with a ... See full summary »



(created by),

Watch Now

From $1.99 (SD) on Amazon Video



Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Johnny 'Vegas' Norris (as Andrew Seeley)
Sarah Edwards ...
Austin Carty ...
Nancy Moreno ...


After Lucas crowns another good game with the winning point, Nathan switches to plan B, inviting him to a party at his dad's luxurious beach house where he cleverly humiliates him with a truth game and a video of Lucas ma calling Dan her dream husband. After Lucas walks out livid, Haley is stranded, accepts a ride back from Nathan in Peyton's car and accepts to keep tutoring him since failing grades would kill all his and Dan's dreams. On his way back Nathan crashes into Lucas in the car of one of Keith's clients; Nathan thinks he can bluff his way out making Tim his false witness, but there are nasty consequences for both brothers, their girls friends and their parents. Written by KGF Vissers

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Drama | Romance | Sport





Release Date:

14 October 2003 (USA)  »

Filming Locations:

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


The episode is named after a song by Dave Matthews Band. See more »


Brooke Davis: [Brooke, Peyton, Natha, Johnny "Vegas" and others are sitting/standing around a table] Hey Lucas.
[Lucas, who was looking in the refrigerator, turns around]
Brooke Davis: Come play.
Lucas Scott: What the game?
Brooke Davis: "I've never".
Johnny 'Vegas' Norris: [after a pause] And yet apparently you have.
Brooke Davis: [after a few "oohs"; laughing] Shut up Vegas!
See more »


Return To Me
Written by Matthew Ryan and Ryan Webb
Performed by Matthew Ryan
Hybrid (Red)
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

I learned something tonight, everyone has secrets
9 February 2013 | by See all my reviews

What does the whole broken water pipe topic have to do with anything in this episode? It is supposed to highlight how poor Karen is? I find it odd that Lucas drives a Jeep, but their house has a plastic shower head hanging up with a piece of wire. Hayley also made a comment about her house being temporary whilst their mansion was being renovated. Perhaps it is because I'm not from America, but I find both their homes charming and beautiful and hardly from the poor side of town and dilapidated.

Yes Hayley is smart, and good with school and supposed to portray the geeky girl. But what is up with the bad fashion and Dawson creek references? That green beanie hat was just so unattractive and it really was just for Lucas to trap her in a lie. I doubt Hayley would have worn that ugly thing, regardless of her IQ, plus the other girls were wearing singlets. Exactly how can one person be so cold as to need a furry hat?

Again I"m not sure of Nathan's motives. Hayley tells him to stop being a jerk, and he seems to be really offended by her words and seems to want to follow them, but then next action is to put that video tape on. Why? Just because Lucas is talking to his girlfriend who I'm not sure he even really likes?

And why is Hayley keeping Nathan a secret from Lucas? I think it is because Hayley really like likes Nathan. She doesn't want to, but there is an attraction on some animal level. Opposites attract and all that.

Interesting note on the video tapes though. Does it mean I'm old to think that 2003 isn't that long ago and surely people still didn't have video tapes then? Its just funny to see them instead of more modern media.

Overall a good episode on the consequence of lying and how the truth is the only safe course of action. One point knocked off for the green furry beanie.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Contribute to This Page