Leo Garvey is being released from prison after serving 7 years of a 10 year sentence. The mention of this on the news makes Oscar and Felix reminisce about the first time they met...serving on Garvey's jury. What should be an open and shut case is dragged on by Felix's search for mitigating circumstances. After lengthy deliberation the jury is sequestered overnight and Oscar and Felix spend their first night together and get their first glimpse of each other's annoying habits. Written by
Did You Know?
Oscar says to Felix that he is a sports writer for the Times, later on through shows run he works for the fictional New York Herald. See more
The second season opening refers to them as merely friends not childhood friends. See more
Spoofs 12 Angry Men