"Murder, She Wrote" Class Act (TV Episode 1989) Poster

(TV Series)

(1989)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Anyone for an Extra Credit Project, Class?
WeatherViolet11 January 2010
Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) introduces and summarizes this "Bookend" guest sleuth episode about an LAPD Lieutenant friend of hers, who, along with two students in his college Criminology course, investigates a closed case murder, in which authorities have, naturally, arrested an innocent suspect.

Its action begins one evening on a California beach near Los Angeles, as a "Young Man" (Bill Brochtrup) hikes along the rocks, preparing to camp beneath the stars, when he witnesses an altercation across a dune and investigates to discover the body of a "Girl" (Holly Clark), as the driver of one automobile speeds away, and the driver of a police patrol car shines his headlights upon the startled Young Man.

LAPD Lieutenant Amos 'Jake' Ballinger (Barry Newman) believes the account of the sole suspect's ailing mother, Anna Gunderson (Gloria Cromwell), who pleads with the Lieutenant to defend her son's innocence, for by now he has been unjustly incarcerated for nearly a year.

When Captain Joe Rawlings (Gerald S. O'Loughlin) dismisses Jake Ballinger from his ongoing investigation, which turns up no other leads, and arranges for Dean Howard Cogden (Robert Casper) to hire Jake as a Criminology instructor on a Los Angeles campus.

Jake is therefore able to provide for his teenage daughter, Jane Ballinger (Heather McAdam), who shares his meager apartment, as they, together manage their domestic responsibilities, while Jane continues her education. But, through this new experience of facing dismissal from the force for disobeying orders, Jake devises a plan to continue the investigation of the now cold case murder, by soliciting volunteers from among his students, to sleuth for extra credit.

And when Jake delivers his extra-credit project before his forum classroom, students begin to drop the course left and right, and then there are three: Moira McShane (Hallie Todd), who bounces the idea around and skips a few classes, Bernard 'Bernie' Berndlestein (Grant Heslov), a geek-ish type, who maintains that information is there to be discovered, and Elizabeth Mills (Lise Hilboldt), who resolves to prove that she is up to any challenge that the police refuse to handle, and able beyond their limited capacity of understanding.

Jane tolerates her father's ongoing rounds of visitors into their humble dwelling at odd hours because she reasons that investigating and proving the innocence of the unjustly accused are woven into his very fabric.

And while Bernie handles the processing of facts and information, Elizabeth makes the rounds to garner clues through her conversations with various sources and suspects, they impressing Jake beyond measure, as he questions their methods, but, of course, they're adamantly focused upon solving the case, by doing things as making plaster casts of tire tracks, and infiltrating the state capitol, at Sacremento.

After deciding that information in the case has been covered up, they question State Senator Andrew Grainger (Robert Pine) and his Chief of Staff, Colin Hale (Robert Lipton), as well as Sam Kendall (Garry Walberg), Joanne Summerfield (Elinore O'Connell), and even Sister Maria (Christina Hart), under the trail of a relative of the senator, who may have shared a past with the murder victim, as the LAPD has its hands full, trying to calm suspects whom they've already cleared, while they simultaneously face exposure by a "Class Act."

The cast is rounded out by Vicki Lynne Davis as Graingers Secretary, Robin Claire as Secretary, and Brett Stimely as Patrolman.

This episode represents the only acting credit each by Vicki Lynne Davis and Elinore O'Connell, the most recent television role each by Robin Claire and Christina Hart, one of three by Holly Clark, and one of the most recent performances by Garry Walberg.

This also marks the first of two "MSW" appearances for Bill Brochtrup, the second of two each for Robert Casper and Lise Hilboldt, the second of three for Barry Newman, the third of three for Robert Lipton, the second of four for Gerald S. O'Loughlin, the second of five for Robert Pine, and the first of seven "MSW" episodes featuring Hallie Todd, before her six as Dennis Stanton's receptionist, Rhoda Markowitz.

Gloria Cromwell, acting on television since 1975, has unfortunately since passed.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Did any MSW potential spin off work?
xbatgirl-300293 March 2022
When these shows were first on, I always thought (what I guess are called) bookend episodes were done just to give Angela L. Some extra time off. Now I understand they were potential spin offs and it makes them more interesting to watch. I can't think of any that actually made it to their own series and it's a shame. I think the concept of a criminology teacher who solves crimes would have been pretty fresh at the time. No other series like it prior to this comes to mind. I'm sure I'm forgetting something, plus surely some TV movies existed. It does seem relatively common now as a concept. This one seems like it had some potential.

I've always liked this lead actor when seeing him here or there and he has a lot of energy and enthusiasm here. I liked the daughter character, even though she's somewhat extraneous as part of a one off mystery, I think she would have been fun in a series. I suppose the insurance investigator would have been a potential love interest. She's another actor I've always liked and would have enjoyed weekly. Her character going off on her own investigations, being slightly competitive with the lead, plus the sexual tension, reminds me of Banacek. I guess especially because of her being an insurance investigator. The only character that didn't work for me was the secretary. I think it was her hacky, stereotypical New York accent & attitude (which seems to exist only on TV).

Shame it didn't work out.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
possible series
Gaslog24 April 2022
Really enjoyed this episode and believe it would be a great basis for a tv series.. A former detective retires and forms his own agency with his pupils as his assistants/partner.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wow...I even preferred this over a Jessica Fletcher episode.
planktonrules6 December 2022
In season three, Angela Lansbury took off an episode and instead of starring in it, she just introduced it. Instead, another amateur sleuth was the star and according to IMDB the series made several 'bookend episodes' where Lansbury got a break from filming and only introduced and sometimes narrated the episodes. Considering she was in her 60s, I cannot blame her for taking some time off!

Most of these bookend episodes are okay but make you wish Lansbury has been in the lead. And, you can assume by the structure of the shows that they were intended as potential spinoff series. Oddly, "Class Act" actually did something no other bookend episode did...it made me wish the network HAD made a series out of it!

In "Class Act", Barry Newman plays a police lieutenant, Jake Ballinger, who is frustrated because one of his cases is closed too quickly. Although a guy confessed to the killing, it seems he might have been coerced into doing this with the promise of a light sentence. And, when Ballinger tries to get the files on the case, they are locked...and no one in the department seems to have access. Obviously some important person has ordered the case to be buried. Additionally, for even asking about the closed case, he's now being punished...taken off active duty and placed in charge of teaching a class at the local university!

While Jake has zero interest in teaching a law enforcement class, he goes. After all, if he doesn't he'll likely be fired. But he finds that the students in the class only took it because they figure it will be an easy A. After dispelling this notion, all but two of his students withdraw. And, with the remaining two students, he decided to investigate the closed case...sort of learning in the field.

This is a really good an intelligently written episode. Most importantly, it left me wanting more and could have worked well as a weekly series....having a small group of eager students helping him work on closed cases or cases which were never solved. Well worth seeing and truly original.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An idea that would've made a good TV series
coltras354 June 2022
Jessica's friend Jake Ballinger, one of the best homicide detectives in Los Angeles, is faced with a case that places his whole career in jeopardy. A woman is killed on a beach and is found by a passerby, who consequently gets arrested and under pressure from the LAPD pleads guilty. However, Jake believes him innocent but his department wants him to forget about the case, and send him to teach to university students about criminology. He ends up teaching two students, one a PI and the other an insurance investigator, and gets them to help on this beach Murder case to find the real killer.

A good idea that is executed quite well with some snappy dialogue, clever investigation. Perhaps, the denouement was a bit slap-dash, but overall very good with a great performance by Barry Newman, who, in my opinion, is a very underrated actor.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Watchable
gjcannon9 September 2023
I came here to see if there was a name for this type of episode which seems to be a trailer for a possible series. The term 'book-ender' is mentioned elsewhere because Jessica introduces and wraps up the story and it says also that these were a way of giving Angela Lansbury a break, but I think that may just be a way of avoiding admitting that episodes like this one really were pilots, but that didn't get the nod. There are several with Keith Michell of this type but I think Barry Newman a cut above and that the character of Ballinger with his trusty student criminologists might have been good for a season or three.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Murder, He Solved" Starring the great Barry Newman!
Somesweetkid18 December 2023
I'm in 100% agreement with the rating and review by "planktonrules." This was a fine episode featuring one of my favorite actors, the late Barry Newman, who just passed away in May 2023, a mere seven months after the wonderful Angela Lansbury departed this Earth, also leaving a major void in the world of television and movie entertainment.

As a matter of fact, I got so involved in this episode that I forgot that it was Murder, She Wrote until Angela's Mrs. Fletcher came in midway to add some minor commentary. As reviewer planktonrules noted, this would have made an intriguing spinoff series with Mr. Newman leading the cast. I especially liked the chemistry and repartee he shared with the student "Elizabeth Mills." Plus, the young actress playing his daughter would have added a nice family dynamic to a new series.

Overall, this is one of my favorite episodes to date, as I'm watching them in sequence on Peacock. I sure will miss Angela and Barry, two talented and natural actors. They were also in another earlier episode at a ski resort and he was fine in that as well.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An average episode with a few fun elements.
Sleepin_Dragon25 March 2021
Jessica recounts a story of murder, a young girl is killed on a beach, and a young man in the wrong place at the wrong time is arrested. Lieutenant Ballinger is on hand to take a second look at the case, with some students. The dynamic of Ballinger having the students was the best element, I especially liked his dynamic with Mrs Mills. Barry Newman is excellent as Lieutenant Ballinger, a very nice character, it's a little odd seeing him here, having seen him a few episodes back as a killer. The character of Mrs Mills, she's feisty, and a little ahead of her time, she was good. It's an ok episode, there is definitely something lacking here, and I would say that is Jessica, it just doesn't offer up anything new or different. Not bad, just forgettable. 6/10.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not quite classy enough
TheLittleSongbird30 September 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

As far as the bookend episodes go, there are certainly worse than "Class Act" before and after. It is a long way from being one of the best 'Murder She Wrote' episodes and one of the lesser episodes of the sixth season. Some of the bookend episodes suffer from Jessica's absence and having a lead character not as compelling. Luckily, what makes "Class Act" better than those episodes is that it does have a compelling lead, aided by a terrific performance from Barry Newman.

Newman is aided very well by Grant Heslov and particularly Lise Hilboldt, the chemistry he has with the latter is one of the biggest charms and high-points of the episode. Some of the story intrigues with some clever parts to the mystery and entertaining classroom scenes.

Production values as ever are slick and stylish. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. The writing is thought-provoking, light-hearted and amiable particularly between Newman and Hilboldt.

However, "Class Act" does have pacing issues. It does drag badly. Extraneous padding, some of it pointless, doesn't help, nor does that not all the characters serve much of a purpose at all. The story does intrigue at times but doesn't feel like a standalone episode of 'Murder She Wrote', more a pilot to a show that never materialised.

Those of Hallie Todd (wasted) and Heather McAdam (could have been left out entirely and one wouldn't miss a thing) are especially pointless and the two actresses struggle to bring anything to them.

In conclusion, decent but not quite classy enough. 6/10 Bethany Cox
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed