An Amish teenage girl begins acting like a non-Amish girl who committed suicide many years ago.
Paul and Alva investigate a young Amish girl, Hannah, who seems to have stigmata yet there has no wounds. Hannah begins to have complete personality changes, turning into a disturbed young socialite from New York. All the clues point to a frightening conclusion that will result in the loss of one of the two girls trapped inside this Plain woman's body.—Jackaldog