"Air Crash Investigation" Kid in the Cockpit (TV Episode 2005) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
More Than One Cause.
rmax30482316 October 2016
It's 1993 and the new Russia is gearing up for the new age with a fleet of Airbus A-310s, very sophisticated. The pilots are a specialized group too, carefully trained. One flight takes off from Moscow. It will fly on an untroubled night across Siberia and then south to land at Hong Kong. Of the three pilots aboard, one has brought some of his family who fly at a discount. It's the kids' first trip abroad and they pay him a surprise visit in the cockpit. The airplane is flying safely on autopilot and Dad lets his daughter sit in the pilot's seat and make a gentle bank, and then his fifteen-year-old son, just as I've done with my kid in an empty parking lot.

The son, Eldar, has only been in the seat for four minutes when the airplane rolls into a 45 degree bank and pins everyone to his seat. The crew and passengers are subject to G forces that barely allow movement. Eldar can't climb out of the seat and his father is desperately giving him orders and trying to reach the control panel with one hand. The airplane goes into a precipitous dive towards the Siberian earth. For a moment, normal G forces prevail and the pilot is able to regain his seat. He and the first officer are wrestling the aircraft successfully when they run out of air space. There are no survivors. The usual overflight for family members is arranged by Aeroflot. The Russians and Brits drop flowers out of the helicopters. The Chinese drop colorful strips of paper with messages written on them. There's nothing "good" about a disaster like this but it's heartening, even if only momentarily, to see the way it draws survivors and families together in doing what Freud called grief work.

The team of investigators is large and determined. The Airbus A-310 is one of the most modern airplanes flying. Is there something wrong with it? Was there a terrorist bomb aboard? What exactly happened? The cockpit voice recorder tells the team that Eldar was in the pilot's seat and allowed to turn the airplane a little bit to the left. In 1993 it wasn't unusual for family members or selected other passengers to visit the cockpit. Now -- since 9/11 -- the rules are far more strict and most cockpit doors are kept locked. But of course every event outside of a physics lab is multi-determined. Eldar, turning the airplane slightly, held the controls in the same position. After 30 seconds the autopilot disengages from the ailerons that control banking without any alarm being sounded. Eldar has flung the airplane into a steep bank and the airplane begins to lose altitude rapidly.

The autopilot, still engaged with the other flight controls, tries desperately to correct the situation but it results in nothing but violent gyrations. The pilots fought the autopilot all the way to the ground, but in fact all they needed to do was let go of the controls and the airplane's safety mechanism would have prevented a stall and brought it back to level flight.

The remains were mostly unidentifiable so all the bodies were cremated and buried in a hero's cemetery that also contains the bodies of the firefighters who died at Chernobyl. The usual corrective measures were deployed. This is an exemplary documentary, both dramatic and informative.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
frightening, unbelievable
existentializer1 September 2007
Hollywood doesn't have writers good enough to come up with a scenario like the Aeroflot 593 disaster, nor could they convince the audience such horror could visit innocent people--but this is a true story, one far stranger than fiction.

I have learned from this series that "planes never crash due to one single cause--there are always two or more causes of any plan crash." The terrifying story of Aeroflot 593 demonstrates how little things can add up to big trouble, especially when a fifteen year-old is seated in the captain's chair.

There is a sliver lining here: you will learn a whole lot about how to fly an Airbus A310 if you watch this episode. Might come in handy; watching this series has frightened me into believing I am doomed to die a horrifying death while desperately sucking the last wisps of pure, calming oxygen from the yellow cup of my oxygen mask, strapped tighter than a snare drum to my violently vibrating seat, white knuckled and frozen in agonizingly tense anticipation of the aircraft finally slamming into a mountainside...or the surface of the ocean...or a suburban neighborhood, mercifully ending this plummeting nightmare and reducing me to a height that no orthopedic insert can improve. But I digress.

Scary, freaky, informative and well re-created (in the absence of a sexual alternative) this is probably as good a way to squander 45 minutes of your remaining life on Earth as I can think of. Good stuff!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
an episode of an event that has to be seen to be believed
La-Luz15 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Before Air Crash Investigations came about, in the UK a Channel 5 documentary was made that had a compilation style program concerning the 'top 10 worst air disasters'. That was around 1998 If memory serves me correctly. This was regarded as the worst one (top) in that list.

This episode then, as the other reviewers have presented in much good detail is a story that is hard to believe. A Russian pilot of elite level decides to treat his kids to a holiday on a brand new spanking Airbus that only a few Russian pilots are commissioned to fly. During the flight, as a treat he invites his kids up to the cockpit and allows both of them to sit at the controls and 'fly the plane'.

For me, having watched this episode a few times is firstly the amazement at how such a professional could behave in the manner that he did (with no objections from his co-pilot peers), but more so how the investigators find out what caused the plane to veer and become uncontrollable. It was only when they did that a realisation of a flaw in the automated flight controls was discovered. One would assume that the scientists and engineers that create this level of intricate technology would be aware of all possible scenarios that can put an aircraft in danger. Seemingly not. It took this air disaster to find it out.

The actual cockpit chaos once things go wrong is quite disturbing to watch and think about, if you put yourself in ther position. And despite the story being a sad, crazy tale it is easily one of the series' best.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed