"Lost" Whatever the Case May Be (2005)

Director:

Jack Bender

Writers:

Jeffrey Lieber (creator) and
J.J. Abrams (creator) ...

TV Series:

"Lost" (2004)

Original Air Date:

5 January 2005 (Season 1, Episode 12)

Genre:

Adventure | Drama | Fantasy | Mystery | Romance | Thriller

Plot:

Kate and Sawyer discover a briefcase and the race begins to win ownership of it. Charlie is still depressed over Claire, and is given a sharp talking to by Rose.

Plot Keywords:

Mysterious Island | Labrador Retriever | Plane Crash | Flashback | South Pacific

Cast

Naveen Andrews	...	Sayid Jarrah
Matthew Fox	...	Jack Shephard
Maggie Grace	...	Shannon Rutherford
Jorge Garcia	...	Hugo 'Hurley' Reyes
Josh Holloway	...	James 'Sawyer' Ford
Malcolm David Kelley	...	Walt Lloyd
Daniel Dae Kim	...	Jin Kwon (credit only)
Yunjin Kim	...	Sun Kwon
Evangeline Lilly	...	Kate Austen
Dominic Monaghan	...	Charlie Pace
Terry O'Quinn	...	John Locke
Harold Perrineau	...	Michael Dawson
Ian Somerhalder	...	Boone Carlyle
L. Scott Caldwell	...	Rose Nadler
Victor Browne	...	Jason - Shooter

Runtime:

43 min

Country:

USA

Language:

English | Korean

Color:

Color

Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1

Sound Mix:

Stereo

Certification:

UK:15 | Portugal:M/12 | USA:TV-14 | Venezuela:PG-13 (DVD rating)

Filming Locations:

O'ahu, Hawaii, USA

Company:

Bad Robot

Trivia:

(Episode #1.12), Shannon describes having been in France and seeing a children's animated movie about "computer fish" that ends with the song "La Mer" (known as "Beyond the Sea" in English). Although Shannon doesn't know the name of the movie, it is clearly Finding Nemo (2003), although the French dub of Finding Nemo, like the original American movie, ended with Robbie Williams's English cover of "Beyond the Sea" instead of the French source. This show and Finding Nemo are both products of the same parent company, Disney. On the DVD region 2 release (Eurpoe/france) the french track does have the french version of Beyond The Sea, this may have only been changed on the DVD release as Williams recorded a french language version for a disc being released of combined hits for a international market, and so may not have been available for a theatrical release.

Goofs:

Continuity: After Sawyer drops the Haliburton out of the tree onto the rocks below, it clearly settles in a different spot from where Kate snatches it up a moment later.

Quotes:

Sawyer: [Kate has headbutted him] Ow, woman. If you wanted to play rough all you had to do was say so.

Movie Connections:

References Finding Nemo (2003)

Whatever the point may be...

"Let the girl go? Man, you have no idea, do you? The girl is the one who set you up. The girl is the one who picked this bank, picked this vault. This whole thing is the girl's idea."

Kate establishes herself as a leader and a plan-maker on the island, and through her bank-robbing flashback in "Whatever The Case May Be", we learn that she made very ethically different plans back in her life before the island. However, instead of contrasting this potentially solid but still poorly executed flashback with a similar tense dilemma on the island, Damon Lindelof and Jennifer Johnson write us an uncharacteristically poor main plot involving Kate, Jack and Sawyer essentially fighting over a briefcase.

The writing is sloppy all over the episode. Sawyer and Jack's exact reasons for being so intent on discovering the case's contents are unclear. Jack makes an out-of-character threat to Sawyer's health to convince Sawyer to give him the briefcase; the scene should have completely destroyed the credibility of both characters, but the actors made the scene seem plausible. The flashback is incredibly cheesy, unoriginal and predictable; it may have been effective if we didn't already know Kate was a fugitive. The episode suffers from weak dialogue saved by a passable effort by the actors, but even they falter on occasion, like Lilly does with her cringe-worthy delivery of the "It belonged to the man I killed!" line that should have been the episode's emotional climax.

More importantly, the entire story seems unimportant, especially when you consider that the toy plane's importance is elaborated upon in a later episode. The episode is overall quite skippable, but it is still a season 1 episode, and as a result still has some substantial positive attributes.

The subplots don't advance any of the story lines particularly far, even if some of the scenes in them are worth watching. Sayid converses with Shannon and Jack, hoping to make something of Rousseau's inscriptions, but in the end the most useful thing they find is a set of song lyrics.

Nonetheless, the episode does foreshadow the next one coming in true season 1 fashion. The gang move their belongings down the beach, and Boone begins to head off to the jungle with Locke regularly, to Shannon's suspicion. Likewise, Sayid and Shannon commence their interactions with one another, despite a disapproving Boone.

But the heart of this episode lies in three brief scenes between Charlie and Rose. Rose's real-world application of Charlie's problems helps him and the viewers get a sense of hope for all the characters. Her endlessly positive attitude is both uplifting and disturbing to an audience who assumes that she is in denial about her husband's obvious death, but hopes they're wrong about the situation. Fans who have watched up until later in the series will likely reflect on this episode as a negative one, but can at least reflect positively upon the days when Rose was less of a stereotype and more of a symbol of hope. Her presence makes one wonder whether or not it would have helped the show to have her, as was originally planned, on the show as a series regular.

"It's a fine line between denial and faith. It's much better on my side."

Standout performances: Matthew Fox, L. Scott Caldwell, Josh Holloway.

Standout scene: Rose consoles Charlie and prays for him.