A runaway girl is found by Mr. Cousin but when Earp investigates the family who adopted her, he decides she should not be returned to it. He decides to try to buy her release from them but may be forced to marry her to gain her freedom.


On Disc

at Amazon


Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Episode cast overview:
Cathy Prentice (as Ann Daniels)
Elizabeth Harrower ...
Mom Prentice
Helen Van Tuyl ...
Mrs. Bates (as Helen Marr Van Tuyl)
Bill Cassady ...
Dr. McCarty
Mayor Jim Kelley
Harry Harvey Jr. ...
Lonnie Prentice
Freeman Morse ...
Norman Davis
Mr. Cousin


Mr. Cousin brings an exhausted girl he found to Dodge City. After taking her to Dr. McCarty who says she needs rest, she is turned over to Mrs. Bates who runs the Traveler's Society to help people. The girl refuses to tell Mrs. Bates who she is or where she is from. However, she is willing to talk to Earp alone although she has little trust in men. She is Cathy Prentice who was adopted by Mom Prentice and lives with her and her sons at Prentice Tavern which is a saloon and hotel at a remote site. Mom has promised her son Todd that Cathy will marry him. Earp investigates the place deciding it is unfit for Cathy and the family is abusive. Mrs. Bates and Mayor Kelley are more worried about the society and city being sued by her family. Earp takes her away from Mrs. Bates who wants her returned to the family while he tries to find Norman Davis a cowhand who was interested in marrying Cathy. Earp only has a couple of options left which may result in him marrying Cathy. Written by Anonymous

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis






Release Date:

24 February 1959 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Production Co:

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


My words of dialog were out of place in 1870's Dodge City i.e. shakedown, drop me a line, and case (as an investigation). These terms belong in the 1950's and after. See more »


Wyatt Earp: [Opening Narration] The 1870s were a time of Victorian decorum and chivalry. Men like Marshal Wyatt Earp held to a code which we smile at today as stuffy and sentimental. Where women were concerned, Wyatt felt obligations which often moved him to be a friend and protector. Historians of the period agreed that life in frontier settlements was heaven for cattle but hard for women, as Cathy Prentice can testify to.
See more »


The Legend of Wyatt Earp
Music by Harry Warren
Lyrics by Harold Adamson
Performed by The Ken Darby Singers
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Message Boards

Recent Posts
Why no 7th Season as the series ended with everything up in air?! troyens
Wyatt's somewhat of a stiff with the ladies corriganville
3 stars in the west thegalaxybeing
Looking For a Western thegalaxybeing
Wyatt Earp in Wichita tscoke@oldwiz.net
Holy smokes!! Wyatt's handing out speed! corriganville
Discuss She Almost Married Wyatt (1959) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: