An ex-ball player that Wolf put away for murder is out of jail and wants revenge.
Nick is forced to confront himself after learning that one of his earliest cases as detective may have resulted in an innocent man going to prison. Ray Bonita was a minor league baseball player on the path to the big leagues when he was convicted for murdering his coach six years earlier. Having become hard and embittered during his time in the "pen", Ray sets out to gain revenge on those he saw as conspiring to convict him all those years ago and begins tracking down Nick (as the arresting officer) after he kills the DA who put him behind bars. Amanda and Lucy help Nick get his old case notes back so he can start to try and figure out what really happened back then. He finally figures out who the original murderer was, but not before tragedy strikes the once-brilliant Bonita.