"Gunsmoke" O'Quillian (TV Episode 1968) Poster

(TV Series)

(1968)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
An Annoying Lead Character
wdavidreynolds11 May 2021
An obnoxious, overbearing Irishman drifter named Leary O'Qullian shoots and kills Curt Tynan in Spearville. The shooting, which occurred during a card game in which both men were cheating, was determined to be justifiable homicide. After his acquittal, O'Quillian leaves Spearville and travels to Dodge City.

In Dodge, the Irishman offends most everyone he meets. He is a know-it-all, and he enjoys drinking and arguing with anyone that will engage him. He starts a brawl inside the Long Branch Saloon. He encourages the girls working at the Long Branch to demand higher wages from Kitty Russell. He accuses Doc Adams of overcharging his patients.

Eventually, Matt Dillon arrests O'Quillian for running afoul of liquor laws. Even in jail, O'Quillian proves to be a handful.

When Curt Tynan's brother Clay learns of Curt's death. He travels to Dodge to find O'Quillian and avenge his brother's death. Naturally, Matt Dillon finds himself and the town in the middle of the situation.

The well-known character actor John McLiam fills the role of Leary O'Quillian. His appearance here follows closely behind his much more serious role as the doomed Herbert Clutter, patriarch of the murdered Clutter family in the film In Cold Blood. McLiam was a fine actor, but his character here is extremely unlikeable.

Victor French plays Clay Tynan. One of his gang members, a man known only as "Chickenfoot," is played by Anthony James. Regular viewers will recall that French and James played the characters Roland Daniel and Elbert Moses just two episodes earlier in "Uncle Finney." It is not unusual for actors to appear several times as different characters in various Gunsmoke episodes, but it is unusual for two actors to play prominent roles in two episodes shown this close together.

Lou Antonio plays Curt Tynan, although his name does not appear in the credits. Antonio was married to actress Lane Bradbury, who played the character Merry Florene in the "Uncle Finney" episode. Antonio would return alongside Bradbury and Anthony James later in Season 14's "Gold Town." Antonio plays Cousin Smiley to the Merry Florene and Elbert Moses characters in that episode.

Look for the actor Iron Eyes Cody in the role of a Native American in this episode. The most interesting aspect of this actor's career is that he played Native American roles his entire career, although he was of Italian descent. He married a Native American woman, and they adopted two Native American boys. Many people will remember him for his role in a "Keep America Beautiful" anti-pollution ad that ran for many years on television where he is seen shedding a tear because of the pollution he sees. This is his only Gunsmoke appearance.

Thematically, this story is remarkably similar to the previous episode, "Slocum." A man acting in self-defense is pursued by relatives of the dead man. The O'Quillian character is nothing like Slocum, the mountain man, however. One almost wishes for Clay Tynan to successfully solve everyone's problem by getting rid of O'Quillian. The annoying nature of the O'Quillan character affects the likeability of this story.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
An episode that is forgettable- and quickly
kfo949414 September 2012
I was unclear if this episode was meant to be a drama or comedy. Which ever way the writers intended the script, it did not play well.

When Irishman Leary O'Quillian shoots a man for cheating in cards in the town of Spearville it will not be long before the dead man's brother will be looking for him. Clay Tynan (Victor French) is the brother looking for Ole O'Quillian. When he enters Spearville he is told that the Irishman went to Dodge but the information about a jury finding it 'Justifiable Homicide' was kept from Clay Tynan. Clay sets out to find the Irishman and kill him.

Inside Dodge O'Quilliam starts trouble with everyone from Miss Kitty to Doc Adams. In fact the only friend that O'Quillian has is the town drunk Louie Pheeters.

When Tynan and his group comes riding into Dodge they want O'Quillian. When O'Quillian comes out into the street a gunfight breaks out. Some people are dead and some alive.

And still I could not tell if it was a drama or comedy.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Two hits in a row for Ron Bishop
grizzledgeezer3 September 2015
This episode immediately followed "Slocum", from another Ron Bishop script. Both are similar stories, about non-conforming people who provoke trouble. *

Unlike Slocum, Leary O'Quillian is not really likable. A talkative Irishman, he seems not only to have kissed the Blarney stone, but swallowed a big chunk of it. He has opinions on everything, most of which (he says) are designed to encourage others to better their lives. He believes the world owes him a living, as one of the "dreamers" who make things better. Matt's view differs: "If you dig a hole in the ground, you're expected to fill it with more than you dug out."

A particularly interesting casting decision has Victor French and Anthony James returning as pretty much the same sort of characters they played in "Hill Girl" and "Uncle Finney" -- except they're not named Florene.

This is "Gunsmoke" at its best, with wonderful dialog and oddball characters. Highly recommended.

* It seems (though I can offer no proof) that "Gunsmoke"'s producers threw out broad story ideas, asking the writers for their own takes. It's not uncommon for two stories in the same season to be thematically similar, though different in details.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed