Carly Beth Caldwell seems to be a target for nearly every joke played in her school. So one Halloween, Carly Beth decides to get revenge. She steals a new mask at a recently-opened store, in a off-limits room, much against the owner's consent. However, this scary new mask seems to be a little too scary, and Carly Beth is having trouble getting it off, leading her and her friend Sabrina to realize that the mask may have attached itself to Carly Beth's face. Written by
Did You Know?
According to R.L. Stine's autobiography, they were going to use a rubber worm in the scene where Carly Beth bites into the sandwich and finds a half-bitten worm, but Kathryn Long insisted on eating a real worm to make it realistic. See more
The first time Carly Beth takes off the mask, it falls to the floor, but it suddenly jumps back up to her hands when she tosses it to Noah. See more
Only you, Carly Beth. You're the only one that ever wanted them, the only one who ever loved them.
Carly Beth Caldwell
No! No! I want it off! I want it off, now! Take it off me! I hate this stupid face! I hate it! I hate it!
Carly Beth, I'm sorry, but this face is your face now.
Green blood drips down the screen in ending credits of every episode. See more
Performed by Jack Lenz See more