"Fantasy Island" The Beachcomber/The Last Whodunnit (TV Episode 1978) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Cute enough, fast paced enough, not 1 annoying actor. Fair enough!
imdb-2528823 November 2022
I was surprised that this story was fast paced enough to keep my interest. I particularly liked the decor of the Mystery story. I doubt that was the real Maltese Falcon prop because that one got mercilessly scraped by Bogie, and this one wasn't, plus this one bent to the side. Probably a close replica. I kept seeing Angela Lansbury mannerisms in the cat lady but I'm not sure why, because that was Olivia de Havilland who played the only Agatha Christie movie I ever saw.

John Astin (face seems vaguely familiar) wasn't annoying, though his story was dull to me, it was well acted and fast paced enough. Oola the vamp was really ugly with her W. Bush nose job and her creepy, evil eyes, and the chunky sister was the prettier, natural-looking one with eyes of innocence.

But that story was so dull! Someone would pay $10K (whatever happened to $50K from season 1?) for being a bum on the beach? Yeah, right! You can go do that by yourself, no need for Roarke's help.

I did think the Holm story was truly a fantasy worthy to be had, because only in a magic place can you act out a script where the characters have come to life... or did they? (Most of the time I shake my head at what idiot, magic-less fantasies the fools pay for!) However, there was 0 magic to be had in this episode, and that was disappointing. Also no spooky (or Halloween vibe) anything here.

I didn't care much at all for the Tattoo storyline this time. The trumpet was annoying and the noise went on for way too long. That poor parrot!

One thing I keep forgetting to mention: "Your fantasy is now over!" Something Roarke would no longer say in later seasons. But it's a bit of a shocker every time I hear him tell that to a guest. I'd be like "Whoa! What I paid for sure didn't go far nor last long!" So far, the only time someone disobeyed Roarke about end of fantasy was Michelle Phillips, when he catches her sucking face with Patrick Wayne. She wanted more and she got more. (Why? He was dull as a plastic knife!)

Highlight of the show: finding Mr. Roarke fine dining with Tattoo in the middle of the "jungle". His self-satisfied air of superiority, as he reclines in his dining throne.

All in all a decent episode, not remarkable, but not annoying in the least. Props for Montalban still saying his welcome with the enthusiasm it required. In way too many episodes of later seasons, he'd just be going thru the motions, like he'd checked out, and he was phoning in his welcome. Not so here. One of the cheeriest greetings he ever delivered.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
not enough soul
stones7827 January 2014
Despite some decent actors and familiar faces which includes John Astin, Jack Carter, Celeste Holm, Maurice Evans, and Janis Paige, this episode misses that certain something that makes the others much better. The "Beachcomber" was particularly weak, as Astin portrays Charles Preston, a family man who wishes to live free by the beach, and leave all his worries behind; it starts to fall flat when Preston is tricked into marrying an overweight island girl, in order to avoid jail. Astin gives it his all, but he was given an underwhelming story to work with. The end of this story does end nice with his real wife Nancy(Lynn Borden)coming to visit him, as she promises that she and their kids will stop taking him for granted and give him the proper respect he deserves. The better story, although still not that great, has Holm playing her favorite writer, and we soon find out that the famous writer was murdered, and Holm decides to stick around to solve the murder; Holm looks amazingly like Angela Lansbury to this writer. The acting in this story is much better, although I thought the conclusion seemed rushed and too convenient; that being said, I did like how her cat and the butler's dog played a part in catching the killers. The most enjoyable aspect for me was watching Tattoo try to play the trumpet, and how it irritated Mr. Roarke.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed