Starting in 1987, three murders were committed on the Western Las Vegas University campus, one of which provided Catherine Willows to investigate a suspect - John Mathers, security guard of... See full summary »



(created by),

Watch Now

From $1.99 (SD) on Amazon Video





Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Kevin Greer
Walter Beerly


Starting in 1987, three murders were committed on the Western Las Vegas University campus, one of which provided Catherine Willows to investigate a suspect - John Mathers, security guard of the university. Mathers was arrested and convicted. Two years ago he was executed. But the night of his execution another murder with the same M.O. was committed. Eventually, Mathers turned out to be a copycat, responsible only for one murder, and the serial killer got away. And today, the evidence found by Greg Sanders at a fresh crime scene leads Catherine to the conclusion that the killer is back. Written by David Shahoumian <>

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis





Release Date:

4 November 2004 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


The team continues working on the unsolved case from CSI: Crime Scene Investigation: The Execution of Catherine Willows (2002). See more »


When the Willows and Grissom are looking at the recently installed hand rail, Willows says that the cement is fresh. The handrail would not be installed using cement, it would be fixed with concrete, of which cement is an ingredient. See more »


[Greg works on live maggots in a container with a scotch tape along its edges]
Catherine Willows: What's with the tape?
Greg Sanders: The evidence wasn't cooperating, so I stuck it to them.
Catherine Willows: [smiling] Cute...
See more »


References What's Eating Gilbert Grape (1993) See more »


Links 234
Performed by Rammstein
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

18 September 2012 | by (UK) – See all my reviews

Real cracker of an episode. The CSI team do seem to excel when they have a case that runs over several episodes. This is the "blue paint" mystery, connected with the killer John Mathers - which was one of the rare cases where Grissom and the team had previously been completely flummoxed.

Big Spoiler:

There's a very good build up of tension here, but the high point is when you finally get to see the serial killer. This is superb acting - in just a few minutes this guy steals the show. There's nothing unusual or immediately menacing about the guy - he looks like a small, not very successful and perhaps frustrated man, who constantly sketches as he's being interviewed; as though the conversation with Grissom is a side- issue. He smiles ruefully, aware that it's game over, and says the last few things he wants to say...

He's not particularly scary - except for the casual way he talks about his murderous exploits, his little secret. But there's something missing in his manner, as one imagines there would be with such a person*. As he chats away, one is acutely aware of the monstrous nature of his crimes, and the sort of ghoulish goings on inside his mind that must have led to them.

(We might use the phrase 'psychopath', but that doesn't help us understand these people on it's own - rather the cool emotional detachment of an otherwise ordinary person that is sometimes reported on encounters with serial murderers)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
Sara Sidle, Queen of CSI Amyfuqu
We don't need any more notoriety. ElspethG
top billing spookiemovies
Season 2 Episode 5 residentevil6901
"Woulda, Coulda, Shoulda" ep from 2008 kelleyscorpio
Constantly confused about differing "Gappy"s... dubjaseff
Discuss What's Eating Gilbert Grissom? (2004) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: