Cindy attends Dixie Canyon Elementary School, located in Sherman Oaks, a suburb of Los Angeles, California, suggesting the area of Los Angeles where the Brady family lives.
Brian Forster, who plays the elf in the school play, would go on to play a member of another famous TV family, that of youngest brother Chris in The Partridge Family (1970). That show aired immediately after "The Brady Bunch" on ABC's Friday night lineup during the 1971-72 and 1972-73 U.S. television seasons ("The Brady Bunch" aired an hour earlier than "The Partridge Family" during the 1970-71 U.S. television season). Forster replaced Jeremy Gelbwaks in the role after that show's first season.
The title is based on the childhood choosing game: "Eenie, meenie, meinie, mo. Catch a tiger by the toe. If he hollers, let him go. Eenie, meenie, meinie, mo. My mother said to pick the very best one, so out goes *you*".
Greg and Peter's baseball team is the Rockets. Greg wears #1, Peter wears #7.