"Bonanza" Once a Doctor (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Doctor Recovers His Nerve
theowinthrop30 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A lot of first rate performers showed up on BONANZA in it's long television reign. One of the best was Michael Rennie, in this particular episode. He plays a man on a wagon train that Hoss (Dan Blocker) is attached to. Rennie's character goes by the name "Professor Poppy", and is very nice but somewhat reticent about his background. He and Hoss become friendly, when another man joins the wagon train named Thomas Crippen (Ashley Cowan). Like "Poppy" he is an Englishman, but of a lower class than Rennie. Crippen recognizes "Poppy" as a Dr. Mundy, who years before botched an operation causing the death of Crippen's wife (highly ironic name and situation here, as historically Dr. Hawley Crippen murdered his wife in 1910). Thomas Crippen proceeds to hound "Poppy" / "Dr. Mundy" for his past mistake. Hoss tries to stick up for his new friend. The crisis comes when the Cockney Crippen decides to even the score, and shoots a man he takes to be Dr. Mundy asleep in Mundy's wagon. Crippen, much to his chagrin, is told whom he has wounded, and is arrested by Sheriff Coffee (Ray Teal), and has to worry if the wounded man can be saved...by Dr. Mundy, who has not practiced medicine since the mistake that cost the life of Mrs. Crippen!

The acting was quite good (most of the time on BONANZA performances were damn good, probably in response to the scripts). Rennie is perfect trying to pull together to redeem his earlier abilities as a Doctor and save the wounded man. It remains a pretty vivid episode to me to this day.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A long way from Harley Street
bkoganbing30 May 2015
One of Bonanza's best episodes involves guest star Michael Rennie playing a fugitive Harley Street physician and surgeon who now is a patent medicine quack running an itinerant show in the American west.

This story actually starts in Great Britain where Rennie flees after an operation where his female patient dies. The husband charged foul play and Ashley Cowan has tracked him to Virginia City.

Poor Dan Blocker's having trouble breaking in those new boots, so much so he's in danger of developing an infection. Michael Rennie sees the problem and provides a medical solution and then Hoss learns of his background and his story.

Later on Rennie's skills as a surgeon come in handy. More I cannot say.

Rennie gives his usual cultivated performance and Ashley Cowan does nicely as the spitfire cockney looking for revenge. The two of them and Dan Blocker make this episode one of Bonanza's best.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed