Bonanza (TV Series) All Ye His Saints (1965) User Reviews

A Child's Search for God

[pacwarbuff · 10/10 · 21 July 2021]

The questioning of God's existence isn't a common storyline in 1960s American television, but it was wise of this episode's writer to ask the tough questions about God and faith via the young Michael character. Just as science fiction was frequently employed for allegorical purposes, the questioning of God by using a child character better allows the audience to accept the premise. I don't think an adult character would have been as convincing. Children want simple, direct answers to their simple, direct questions. The story is further helped by Clint Howard's brilliant performance.

The scene between Ben and Joe is outstanding. Michael Landon, despite all of his career achievements, is still a criminally underrated actor, and he's so effective in this story. His every line is delivered with conviction and meaning. Joe is so close to falling apart throughout the episode. So many times the Cartwrights help a guest character, but this time a regular character -in this case, Joe-is actually emotionally connected on a personal level rather than just in the usual Compassionate Cartwright way.

Impressive performances by the entire cast. There are lots of layers to Tom Cain (Leif Erickson) and while Tom Cain is a mere man, he possesses a good deal of wisdom.

Special mention should also be made of David Rose, who composed a beautiful music score for "All Ye His Saints."

My Rating: 10/10.

Climb the mountain, search for God

[bkoganbing · 6/10 · 1 June 2016]

Both Hoss and Little Joe witness a terrible freak accident where Simon Scott is shot with his own weapon. As he clings to life little Clint Howard listens intently to hired hand Rudolfo Acosta tell him that God lives up high and one should seek him out in prayer.

But Howard takes his meaning literally and runs off to the high country looking for God. And when he finds big Leif Erickson with a beard like an Old Testament prophet, who's to tell him this isn't God?

But Erickson is far from God, in fact he's a long wanted fugitive that was presumed dead. He's a most dangerous and cynical man.

Bonanza regulars take a back seat to the guest stars in this episode. Erickson and Howard are something special together. And it's not often you see Rudolfo Acosta who is usually very bad Indians or Mexicans play a good guy. It's a nice story about a child's faith.