IMDb > "Babylon 5" Secrets of the Soul (1998) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
"Babylon 5" Secrets of the Soul (1998)

« Prev | 95 of 110 Episodes | Next »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

1 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

You're a low, pitiful little man, Dr Franklin

1/10
Author: Andariel Halo (phenomynouss@hotmail.com) from Here
8 November 2010

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

One of the plots of this episode involves discovering that the Vorlons actually made telepaths over 9000 million years ago or whatever.

The main plot that receives more time involves Dr Franklin prying into a species called the Hyach, shocked that their modern historical records only go back a few hundred years, whereas they have been spacefaring for longer than that.

So because Dr Franklin says he needs ALL possible information about the Hyach in order to help them with a disease and declining birth rates. Because the Hyach are too damn stupid to give him a good reason not to pry, and actively behave suspiciously, he breaks into their records, and discovers via a lone surviving transmission that there was a species on the Hyach planet called Hyach-doh.

The Hyach then, rather than pressing charges against him for breaking and entering or espionage, just admit to him freely that there used to be a species called Hyach-doh on their planet thousands and thousands of years ago, and the Hyach annihilated the entire species, and it turns out OOPS the Hyach-doh were necessary for interbreeding with the Hyach, as the Hyach birth rates begin to rapidly decline over the years, threatening them with extinction.

Leaving aside the incredibly flimsy explanation and shady pretexts and the typical run-of-the-mill sci-fi complete misunderstanding of evolution, they then tell Dr Franklin that this was a shameful period of their history, so much so that they've actually gone to great measures to suppress this part of their history... which begs the question of how exactly these two are so well-versed in it, unless they mean suppress it from outsiders learning of it, which would make sense.

However, Dr Franklin says he CANNOT FORGIVE them... EVEN THOUGH these two Hyach weren't even alive back then and couldn't have done anything and are against genocide and everything else. He says he STILL cannot forgive them.

And he's supposed to be a doctor? A saver and healer of lives? An educated man who learned not to hate the Dilgar after learning that a Dilgar doctor had saved the lives of his father and other Earth soldiers when all the other Dilgar that had captured them wanted to? The same Dilgar doctor then being executed by the other Dilgar for saving them? This coming from a man whose national ancestry (given his American accent) includes the genocide of millions of native tribal peoples, not even expanding upon his entire race, having committed countless vehement, vicious, genocidal acts in their history, including arguably rendering a whole sentient species (Homo neanderthalensis) extinct? You're a low, pitiful little man, Dr Franklin.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 17 people found the following review useful:

More dull stuff carried over from the previous dull episode

5/10
Author: planktonrules from Bradenton, Florida
8 June 2007

Season five for Babylon 5 was, generally speaking, a disappointment. As the Shadows AND the Earth had been defeated, there were no enemies when the season began and the episodes just seemed to be in limbo--probably because originally there wasn't even supposed to be a fifth season.

Once again, a major focus of the episode are the telepaths aboard B-5 and once again, they and their leader are an amazingly dull group. In addition, the doctor learns a shocking truth about a race called the Hyachs. The problem is that none of this really seemed very interesting and it seemed like the show was just spinning it's wheels, so to speak. A real snoozer.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history