Sally, played by Bethanny Nurse, suggests that the mute girl in the ghost story may have been deaf. In her next appearance in "The Tale of the Closet Keepers", Bethanny Nurse's character was a deaf girl.
The first time Gary says his usual "I declare this meeting of the Midnight Society closed."
Laura Bertram who played Amanda, reappeared again a couple years later as Laurel in the fifth season episode "The Tale of the Mystical Mirror"
Laura Bertram is the older sister of Jennifer Bertram who appeared in the series revival's episode "The Tale of the Hunted" as Laura.
Jennie Lévesque who played The Lonely Ghost would later appear again in the first season as Christina Carr in "The Tale of the Dark Music".