The Kingfish (Tim Moore) is mistaken for a matrimonial agent by Juliet Williams (Zelda Cleaver), a plain-looking woman in her forties. He devises a scheme to collect a fee by convincing Andy (Spencer Williams) that the best bride is a mature one. Andy can't afford an engagement ring, so The Kingfish "borrows" his wife's while she is asleep, to finalize the deal. Learning of Andy's engagement, Sapphire (Ernestine Wade) invites Juliet to a party, and that's when the complications set in.