According to Jim: Season 4, Episode 17
The Mustache (8 Mar. 2005)
TV Episode | TV-PG | | Comedy
Following attractive delivery girl Alicia's suggestion, Jim grows a mustache. Cheryl hates it and tries to make him lose it by dying her hair dark - but Jim loves it! Then Cheryl meets Alicia and starts manipulating Jim through her.
From $1.99 on Amazon Instant Video