According to Jim: Season 4, Episode 10
Stalking Santa (14 Dec. 2004)
TV Episode - - Comedy
Christmastime. A man bumps his car into Jim's car and upsets him. Cheryl talks Jim into settling the issue officially. When Jim sees the man as Santa at the shopping mall, he gets into a dust-up with him. And things snowball from there.
Director:Philip Charles MacKenzie
From $1.99 on Amazon Instant Video