We Live in Public (2009)

User Rating:

7.4/10   

Director:

Ondi Timoner

Release Date:

13 November 2009 (UK)

Genre:

Documentary

Plot:

A documentary focusing on the life of dot-com entrepreneur Josh Harris, and his exploits over the last decade.

Plot Keywords:

Internet | Online

Awards:

1 win

Cast

Tom Harris	...	Brother
rest of cast listed alphabetically:
David Amron
Alex Arcadia
Zero Boy
Brett Brewer
Owen Bush
Jason Calacanis
Cal Chamberlain
Tanya Corrin
Jeffrey Deitch
Chris DeWolfe
Abby Ellin
Feedbuck
Leo Fernekes
Donna Ferrato
Robert Galinsky
Missy Galore
Marc Geiger
Jeff Gompertz	...	Capsule hotel / pods installation artist
Anthony Haden-Guest
Jon Harris
Josh Harris	...	Himself
Nico Haupt
Alana Heiss
Max Heller
David Hershkovits
Harold Kaufman
Leo Koenig
Hillary Koob-Sassen
Gabriella Latessa
Mangina
Andy Morris
Gabrielle Penabaz
Nacho Platas
Stephanie Platas
Michael Portnoy
Adeo Ressi
Douglas Rushkoff
Ashkan Sahihi
Nancy Smith
Gabriel Snyder
Tara Subkoff	...	(archive footage)
Nikolas Van Egten
Josh White
Fred Wilson
Jessica Zaino

Runtime:

USA:90 min (Sundance Film Festival)

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color

Company:

Interloper Films

Quotes:

Josh Harris: lions and tigers used to be kings of the jungle & then one day they wound up in zoos - i suspect we're on the same track

A Fascinating Film about a Peculiar Internet Pioneer

This film was shown at the SXSW Film Festival in Austin, TX after winning the grand jury prize at Sundance. It was well received in Austin as well. It is a fascinating look at the early days of the Internet through the biography of one its pioneers Josh Harris. The film is well-done in a technical sense and fascinating ride, but I'm not sure if it ever figures out if it's a history of an industry, a study of the social impact of Internet, or a biopic about the peculiar mad scientist, John Harris. It tries to be all of these things and thus perhaps undermines its own ability to completely succeed at any of them.

The film is informative in filling in some of the early history and Harris's key role with the mostly forgotten 1990s pioneering ventures of Jupiter Communications and Pseudo.com. But Harris seems to move away from his role as a computer nerd and begins to evolve into a dysfunctional performance artist who seems to want to demonstrate that the Internet will break down all remnants of human privacy. The film maker seems to want emphasize his visionary qualities in which he is predictive of today's MySpace and Facebook culture.

However, this reviewer doesn't find his bunker experiment or his living in public online to be particularly insightful or predictive. The whole concept was more-or-less foreshadowed in Jim Carrey's Truman Show in the 1990s. Nor is it particularly predictive. Harris was creating venues in which people were forced to live in public in front of cameras with predictably unhealthy and destructive results. Today, we choose voluntarily how much of our lives to allow the public – and really only our chosen friends – to view online. The difference between everyone's lives being on display and allowing our friends to see limited glimpses of our lives is vast. Harris seems like a tragic and self-destructive figure, who is constantly rewriting his own experiences in his own mind. He is estranged from his family and unable to establish and maintain intimate relationships.

In the end, he seems to have stranded himself on his own Gilligan's Island (with which he is obsessed). He is either a clown (another one of his characters) or simply a reclusive madman. The film provides an intriguing picture of an internet pioneer who went off the deep end, but I'm not sure if it achieves its goal of truly using Josh's experiences to critique the virtual world that he played a key early role in helping construct. The virtual world, for all its flaws, is not the world of total public voyeurism that Josh imagined it would become.