IMDb > Middle Sexes: Redefining He and She (2005) (TV)

Middle Sexes: Redefining He and She (2005) (TV) More at IMDbPro »


Overview

User Rating:
7.2/10   121 votes »
Your Rating:
Saving vote...
Deleting vote...
/10   (delete | history)
Sorry, there was a problem
MOVIEmeter: ?
Down 70% in popularity this week. See why on IMDbPro.
Director:
Writer:
Contact:
View company contact information for Middle Sexes: Redefining He and She on IMDbPro.
Release Date:
May 2005 (UK) See more »
Genre:
Plot:
Examines the diversity of human sexual and gender variance around the globe, with commentary by scientific experts and first-hand accounts of people who do not conform to a simple male/female binary. | Add synopsis »
Awards:
2 nominations See more »
User Reviews:
An intellectually dishonest apologist diarrhoea See more (4 total) »

Cast

  (in credits order)

Gore Vidal ... Narrator (voice)
rest of cast listed alphabetically:

Calpernia Addams ... Herself
Beth Aynsley ... Character Voiceover
Max Beck ... Himself
Tamara Beck ... Herself
Milton Diamond ... Himself - University of Hawaii (as Prof Milton Diamond)
Alice Dreger ... Herself - Michigan State University (as Prof Alice Dreger)
Anne Fausto-Sterling ... Herself - Brown University (as Prof Anne Fausto-Sterling)
Louis Gooren ... Himself - Free University Hospital Amsterdam (as Prof Louis Gooren)
Sylvia Guerrero ... Herself

Andrea James ... Herself
Shivananda Khan ... Himself - Naz Foundation International (as Shivananda Khan OBE)
Luke ... Himself - Noah's Older Brother
Michelle ... Herself - Noah's Mother
Mike ... Himself - Noah's Step-Father
Noah ... Himself
James Pfaus ... Himself - Concordia University Montreal (as Dr James Pfaus)
Richard ... Himself - Noah's Father
Joan Roughgarden ... Herself - Stanford University (as Dr Joan Roughgarden)
A.W. Richard Sipe ... Himself (as Prof A.W. Richard Sipe)
Gloria Wekker ... Herself - University of Utrecht (as Dr Gloria Wekker)
Sam Winter ... Himself - University of Hong Kong (as Prof Sam Winter)
Lester Wright ... Himself - Western Michigan University (as Dr Lester Wright)

Directed by
Antony Thomas 
 
Writing credits
(in alphabetical order)
Antony Thomas 

Produced by
Nancy Abraham .... supervising producer: Home Box Office
Carleen L. Hsu .... producer (as Carleen Ling-an Hsu)
Liz McLeod .... executive producer: Granada Television
Sheila Nevins .... executive producer: Home Box Office
Antony Thomas .... producer
Alexander Ward .... associate producer (as Alex Ward)
 
Original Music by
Dimitri Tchamouroff 
 
Cinematography by
Jonathan Partridge (director of photography)
 
Film Editing by
McDonald Brown 
 
Production Management
Ruth Cody .... production manager
 
Sound Department
Simon Farmer .... sound recordist
Ed Novek .... additional sound
John Valadez .... additional sound
Tim Wheeler .... dubbing mixer
 
Camera and Electrical Department
Jack Cochran .... additional photography
Elia Lyssy .... additional photography
Dirk Nel .... additional photography
Brian Robertshaw .... gaffer
 
Editorial Department
Aidan Farrell .... colorist
Ian Goff .... on-line editor
Anna Ksiezopolska .... additional editor
Scott Thomas .... on-line editor
 
Other crew
Rebecca Auld .... production coordinator
Stephanie Burke .... production coordinator
Gavin Hill .... location co-ordinator: Thailand
Shernaz Italia .... location co-ordinator: India
Ben Johnston .... production runner
Freny Khodaiji .... location co-ordinator: India
Elizabeth Klinck .... researcher
Chandra Van Binnendijk .... location co-ordinator: Suriname
Eddy Van der Hilst .... location co-ordinator: Suriname
 

Production CompaniesDistributorsOther Companies

Additional Details

Runtime:
54 min | USA:74 min (DVD version)
Country:
Language:
Color:
Aspect Ratio:
1.33 : 1 See more »
Sound Mix:
Certification:

FAQ

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
0 out of 1 people found the following review useful.
An intellectually dishonest apologist diarrhoea, 1 December 2014
Author: azcoppen from Los Angeles, USA

I was strongly pushed to watch this as an alternative perspective on the "toxicity" of conventional masculine identity, and to gain a wider understanding around scientific "advances" i allegedly may have missed. Wary of my own views and the degenerative nature of confirmation bias, i tried hard to retain an open mind. It's difficult to stay friendly to this film, because like a lot of LGBT material, it can be disingenuous, and bordering on potentially manipulative. Strong words, perhaps - but justified.

First thing to know is that Gore Vidal was a) gay, and b) a very strong campaigner against gender "essentialism"; even going so far to advocate human pansexuality. It's also disappointing to see Indian-born Anthony Thomas being responsible for this kind of editorial guff.

Those looking for an objective or circumspect - dare i say, critical - look at the fascinating subject of gender and human sexuality will feel cheated. There is a real bias at work, and it's the fact that the doc presents itself as an honestly naturalistic, rounded look at scientific issues such as foetal development and social determinism, is what makes it so distasteful.

And speaking of science, you'll get steadily angrier if you work in a scientific profession as the minutes go on and on. Using science to make an argument is one thing; misrepresenting it is another. Add that to the "objective" sales tag, and you have a toxic combination. If, of course, you *want* to believe the suggestions because you already believe them anyway, and don't care whether its validated as reliable, it won't matter too much.

For example: if you can watch pseudo-scientists explaining that all animals actually breed just because it "feels good" (like male black widow spiders who have a sexual "experience"), that sexual "rules" appeared subject of natural variance that the West somehow misinterprets, or how gender identity disorder apparently is a misunderstanding of Karma (because we all are ladyboys - no, seriously), you are a much more patient person than i am. There are unquestionably biological factors that come into play, but when you hear narration using politically charged terms like "intersex" (i.e. hermaphrodite) and "binary" genders, straining to use it a basis for disqualifying male/female normality, you can't take the interviewees seriously.

You also can't make non-sequitur/straw-man arguments about the same lower hormonal activity producing "underdeveloped" genitalia as infant gender variance, when your next point confirms that the same subjects have... fully-developed genitalia.

The simple fact is that this is apologism masquerading as legitimate scrutiny, pure and simple. And that's fine, if you just want to watch something that confirms the bad ideas you have that you'll never challenge anyway.

The same old clichés and poor thinking are around every corner: Eastern religions are more accepting in their enlightened wisdoms (when they're not doing animal sacrifice, honor rape etc), humans are actually pansexual, sexuality is fluid (yawn), everyone's so judgemental, nobody is actually heterosexual, sexuality is about feeling and relationships, boys have nipples, anyone who has boundaried views on sexuality is actually afraid of their own confused feelings (homophobes are closet homosexuals), on and on.

The loudest, most obnoxiously absent smoking gun in the whole rotten abyss of bad ideas is the abject lack of any conversation or examination of sexual *morality*, in any form: the existence or variance in moral sexual reasoning, or even the idea that humans subscribe to a moral framework around identity/gender, sexual behaviour, or any contemplation on the negative consequences of sexual choices (aggression, infidelity, disease, distress etc). Absolutely none, of any viewpoint. The filmmakers don't seem to hold any moral perspective, of any form - good or bad, left or right - there is no acknowledgement it is even linked.

This film is trying to sell you something - and it's really, really trying. But it doesn't want you to think it's selling, so it's lacquered in a "compassionate" or "intellectual" guise.

The most worrying aspect of films like these is that people who wouldn't describe themselves as scientifically or philosophically-minded watch them, and are fooled into concluding they've seen an insightful, "smart" or "deep" look at something, simply because it *appears* legitimate. This kind of defensive grade-school reasoning belongs in a tedious college philosophy class of short-sighted San Francisco backpackers, not on a DVD shelf.

Was the above review useful to you?
See more (4 total) »

Message Boards

Discuss this movie with other users on IMDb message board for Middle Sexes: Redefining He and She (2005)

Recommendations

If you enjoyed this title, our database also recommends:
- - - - -
The Opposite Sex: Rene's Story For the Bible Tells Me So Dangerous Living: Coming Out in the Developing World In My Shoes: Stories of Youth with LGBT Parents Thy Will Be Done
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
Show more recommendations

Related Links

Full cast and crew Company credits External reviews
IMDb Documentary section IMDb USA section

You may report errors and omissions on this page to the IMDb database managers. They will be examined and if approved will be included in a future update. Clicking the 'Edit page' button will take you through a step-by-step process.