IMDb > Pigeon (2004) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Pigeon More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 reviews in total 

9 out of 9 people found the following review useful:

An outstanding short that deserves an Academy Award Nomination!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

10/10
Author: MEHDI NUR from Toronro, Canada
6 February 2006

This film deserves to be amongst the titles of the greats. It is full of insightful moments of fear and compassion in such a short yet powerful journey. The story takes place during World War Two, as an older Jewish, man played by Michael Lerner, gets on to a train in order to escape Nazi occupied France only to be left at the mercy of a German Officer. At this point the character played by the wonderful Wendy Crewson gets involved.

This piece is based on a true story and superbly acted by both Lerner and Crewson, with superb cinematography by Mitchell T. Ness. It is beautifully directed by the great up and coming director Anthony Green who is hugely talented and who will, at this rate, be at the top of his game in no time soon.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Short Time, High Impact

10/10
Author: Lloyd Bowman from Philadelphia, Pa.
23 March 2008

I'm fortunate enough to get to see short films through a program on public television called "The Short List" which seasonally features selected short films from around the world.

Wow! What a dramatic impact in such a short time. In the space of about 10 minutes this film builds to a point of high suspense. Also, inside of that time, we are introduced to man, given insight into his character, shown the wide variety of emotions that pass through him -- all without a word from the actor. The other major character in the film her own triumph in acting on two levels: someone who is acting as though she is acting.

Mysteriously, as of this writing more than half of the raters have given this film the supreme rating of 10, but its overall IMDb rating hovers around 4.0. Huh???!

This is a great little film. Its makers should proud and you should be so lucky as to see it.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Great Symbolism

10/10
Author: Jessica Henri from United States
16 April 2012

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

I have recently seen this film in my enhanced English class. We watched it once with sound, then muted it. This film strategically places subtle symbolism. In the first part where the man sits on the bench, you don't notice it at first, but when you watch it again (as I have), you notice that behind him is a train car. Much like the ones used to deport Jews. (which if you didn't notice, the main character is one. You see him praying on the train when he realizes his papers are gone.) Can someone say "foreshadowing"?? When he saves the pigeon, he is transforming from a bystander to a hero. He saves the pigeon. In the train, the woman he has never ever met before saves him. But in the end, notice how the pigeon is dead. What do you think will happen to the man? He will most likely die. As his situation and the pigeon's is similar, I assume that he will be caught and either sent to a concentration camp from a train car or will be shot dead. So even though he was saved, he will still die. This movie had excellent camera work and I loved the music and how minimalistic the dialogue was. Thank you for reading.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Awards Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history