An Unreasonable Man (2006)

Directors:

Henriette Mantel
Steve Skrovan

Writers (WGA):

Henriette Mantel (written by) &
Steve Skrovan (written by)

Genre:

Documentary | Biography

Tagline:

Ralph Nader : How Do You Define a Legacy?

Plot:

A look at the career of consumer advocate Ralph Nader from wannabe presidential candidate to public pariah. |

Plot Keywords:

Political Activist | Independent Film

Awards:

2 nominations

Cast

Ralph Nader	...	Himself
Pat Buchanan	...	Himself
Howard Zinn	...	Himself
rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Eric Alterman	...	Himself
Theresa Amato	...	Herself
Byron Bloch	...	Himself
David Bollier	...	Himself
Barry Burden	...	Himself
Joan Claybrook	...	Herself
Phil Donahue	...	Himself
Andrew Egendorf	...	Himself
Robert Fellmeth	...	Himself
Mark Green	...	Himself
William Greider	...	Himself
Richard Grossman	...	Himself
Gene Karpinski	...	Himself
Justin Martin	...	Himself
Morton Mintz	...	Himself
James Musselman	...	Himself
Claire Nader	...	Herself
Laura Nader	...	Herself
Lawrence O'Donnell	...	Himself
James Ridgeway	...	Himself

Directed by
Henriette Mantel
Steve Skrovan

Writing credits (WGA)
Henriette Mantel		(written by) &
Steve Skrovan		(written by)

Produced by
Kevin O'Donnell	....	producer

Original Music by
Joe Kraemer

Cinematography by
Mark Raker

Film Editing by
Beth Gallagher
Alexis Provost

Production Management
K.D. Gulko	....	post-production supervisor

Sound Department
Craig Clark	....	sound re-recording mixer
Craig Clark	....	supervising sound editor
Danny Kim	....	sound effects editor
Craig Schafer	....	sound re-recording mixer

Camera and Electrical Department
Melissa R. Donovan	....	unit cinematographer

Animation Department
Dan Lovell	....	animator (uncredited)

Other crew
Bryan Heffron	....	production assistant
Ellie Knaus	....	production coordinator

Thanks
Philip Alberstat	....	thanks (as Phil Alberstat)

Production Companies

• Submarine Entertainment
• Two Left Legs

Distributors

• IFC First Take (2007) (USA) (theatrical)
• Red Envelope Entertainment (2007) (USA) (theatrical)

Other Companies

• Digital Film Tree  post consulting and integration
• Digital Film Tree  post digital services
• Roundabout Entertainment  sound re-recording
• Sloss Law Office  legal
• Soundtrack  trailer
• William Morris Independent  sales

Runtime:

USA:122 min

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color

Certification:

USA:Not Rated

Company:

Submarine Entertainment

Quotes:

Ralph Nader:Let it not be said that this generation refused to give up so little in order to achieve so much.

Movie Connections:

Edited into "Independent Lens: An Unreasonable Man (#9.9)" (2007)

But More Reasonable than Republicans and Democrats?

This documentary is a chronicle of Ralph Nader's life and times, with an above-average dose of commentators. They are many: Nader's associates and many journalists, and others ranging from Phil Donahue to Pat Buchanan, but the latter is there for additional perspective on Nader, not debating points. Indeed, while the commentators support the documentary narrative on Nader's background, activities (including Nader's Raiders), and accomplishments, the biggest debate is on whether Nader did the right thing in not abandoning his independent Presidential bid in 2000 and perhaps costing Al Gore the election.

Some material on Nader's background is included, from his birth in Winsted, Ct. His parents were Lebanese immigrants. His mother was a political activist, and his father ran a restaurant and a bakery, helping shape Nader's lifelong affection for the marketplace and the consumer, as well as political discourse, for the restaurant was a haven for political discussion. The town-meeting-type government, in which Nader's family participated, with citizens voting on laws, was seen by Nader as pure democracy at work. Nader was bright and went to Harvard Law School, and he had a friend become paraplegic because of an auto accident.

Nader has championed many consumer issues. Auto safety, Nader's first claim to fame, is focused on most early and prominently and is a recurring theme, perhaps most appropriately. He took on GM, Ford, and Chrysler on seat belts to pollution control to steering mechanisms, and this is covered well, along with their twisted efforts to discredit him (even by extremely sleazy methods invading his privacy).

As for Nader's candidacy for President in 2000, the commentators debate extensively and, at some moments, venomously. He arguably cost Gore the election versus a reactionary President, and was his staying in until the end justified? But Nader ran because of what he believed in, thinking Democrats had become too much like Republicans. As the documentary covers at length, this had been a theme of Nader's political existence since the time of Nixon and Ford. Jimmy Carter turned out to be undependable in Nader's eyes, but the big problem really arose with the election of Reagan, the force of whose personality made people forget the difference between right and wrong, including on consumer issues. Regulations with their roots in Nader were opposed and sometimes successfully thrown out. Nader saw a lack of sympathy and agreement with his concerns continue through Democratic President Bill Clinton, whose Vice President was Gore. All in all, Nader's stubbornness in 2000 can be attributed to long-time frustration, not just recent events. Hence, the title of the movie, based on George Bernard Shaw's quote.

Nader's contribution on environmental (clean water and air) and safety matters outside of autos could have been discussed a little more. Another possible item for inclusion might have been some specifics on some laws and regulations, enacted and recommended; then, it might have been interesting to hear debate on whether he was right or was going too far, etc. However, this documentary ran more than two hours as is, and it is very well done; it will be thoroughly enjoyed by anyone interested in the subject matter.