IMDb user comments for
Smokin' Aces (2006) More at IMDbPro »

3 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
It's a mad mad mad mad assassination., 11 February 2007

Author: dunmore_ego from Los Angeles, California

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Occam's Razor: "The explanation requiring the fewest assumptions is most likely to be correct." In other words, "Simpler is better." *Smokin' Aces* is a walloping actioner with way too much exposition.

There is more unnecessary dialog here than in the Pam and Tommy sex tape.

Plot is simple: a mobbed-up magician/card shark, Buddy 'Aces' Israel (Jeremy Piven) is about to canary to the FBI. Holed up in a Lake Tahoe hotel penthouse, the mob wants him dead – thank you, Captain Obvious! - and puts out not just a contract, but a bounty on his head for one million dollars. Out to scalp him is every vicious criminal and gunslinger in the west - rustlers, cutthroats, murderers, bounty hunters, desperadoes, mugs, pugs, thugs, nitwits, half-wits, dimwits, vipers, snipers, con men, Indian agents, Mexican bandits, muggers, buggerers, bushwhackers, horse thieves, train robbers, bank robbers, ass-kickers and Methodists.

And writer-director Joe Carnahan (bastard spawn of Guy Ritchie) is intent on giving us back story on each and every one. With jump cuts slamming enough to knock over an elephant, we are introduced to crooked cops led by Ben Affleck, goth-insane Tremor Brothers, a steel-speared Persian-looking guy, a Welsh master of disguise, various other pain-meisters and do-badders – there's even an Ambiguously Lesbian Duo! And all the while we're wondering - if these muthas are so publicly badass, how is it that they haven't been arrested/killed/given a reality series yet? For pure visceral entertainment, this is the movie for you – problem is it loses focus: is it aiming for a gut-level slam to the reptilian brain, or trying to unspool a complex story with a half-relevant twist at the end? I'm here for the visceral, please stop with the dialog – too much talki- stop the talking! There's just TOO MUCH TALKING! A discernible thread is that of the two cops, Carruthers and Messner (Ray Liotta and Ryan Reynolds), trying to stop the hit, with Andy Garcia (supersuave as always) their superior officer with ulterior agenda.

Jason Bateman scene-steals as an alcoholic, cross-dressing sleaze bag lawyer (nothing new, I know), Tommy Flanagan is chilling as the *Leon*/Hannibal master of disguise, and Ben Affleck does some of his best acting while he lies dead and his killer works his mouth like a puppet (the same method that was used in *Gigli*).

The most disturbing murder is the intimate one, when Nestor Carbonell (as the Persian-looking guy) spears Bill the Security Guard and almost sensuously embraces him 'til death.

Aussie Joel Edgerton does such a fantastic job of assimilating first his Russian character and then Tommy Flanagan's assassin character (who wears his rubber face - in reality, it is Joel playing the assassin) that we actually believe he is first a klutz Russian and then a nerveless assassin.

There are some well-directed, tense moments, the usual shoot-em-up melees, an emphatic, tear-streaming performance from Jeremy Piven, with a half-lame twist at the end that prompts – you guessed it – more talking, as Ryan Reynolds actually says to Andy Garcia, the mastermind behind the quasi-scam, "Make it all make sense."

Add another comment

Related Links