My Brother's War (2005)

User Rating:

5.1/10   

Director:

Whitney Hamilton

Writer:

Whitney Hamilton (writer)

Genre:

Drama

Tagline:

Over four hundred women fought disguised as men during the Civil War. This is one woman's story.

Plot:

On the day of her engagement, Grace Kieler finds her family and fiancé divided on political matters...

Plot Keywords:

Lesbian | Historical | Apostrophe In Title | Period Romance | George Mcclellan

Cast

Whitney Hamilton	...	Grace / Henry Kieler
Dana Bennison	...	Virginia Klaising
Rebecca Damon	...	Georgianna Walker
Patrick Melville	...	Lucius Walker
Thom Milano	...	Colonel Wright
Rick Lewis	...	Stanford Davis
Vincent Niemann	...	Thomas Kieler
Grace Pettijohn	...	Ruth Cooper
William Laney	...	General McClellan
Patrick Sullivan	...	Irish Rebel
Bryce 'Paul Mama' Williams	...	Preacher
Brooke Wood	...	Clara Quigley
Jennifer Larkin	...	Gert Blaylock
Maureen Raccioppi	...	Virginia's Sister
Nicholas Raccioppi	...	Virginia's son

Runtime:

USA:115 min (original version)

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color

Sound Mix:

Stereo (RCA Sound System)

Filming Locations:

Fort Greene, Brooklyn, New York City, New York, USA

Company:

Bjornquist Films

I'm sure there were good intentions

I apologize to Ms. Hamilton who clearly devoted a great deal of time, energy, and love to this project, but the final product here is really not very good. It's her first screenplay to make it to film, her directorial debut, and she is the lead character. I am sure she will improve as her experience grows.

In the first 20 minutes, there were at least 25 scene cuts with few lasting as long as 90 seconds. But that made sense in the bigger view because the characters had incredibly little to say. Not much of what they said was trite, but there was virtually nothing in which to engage a viewer in the story except to continue questioning when this forced pushing of the story along to the real stuff was going to end. One scene at a dinner table had some good dialog, but even that ended abruptly and it was the longest scene of the first 25.

There were also some elements that compromised the realism of the story. Some of these may have come from budget issues in what is obviously an independent and very privately, maybe singularly, financed film. A lone Confederate tent in the middle of a field for what is supposed to be Longstreet's 1st Virginia Rifles, a soldier with a shoulder wound and, 15 minutes later - albeit 22 scenes later, not even a hole in his jacket sleeve. That soldier deciding alone that his friend should "infiltrate" the Federals and become a spy. She should have had at least SOMEONE in a command position in the script to look like he was going through the camp recruiting spies - but then again, there was no camp. Although, the dinner scene was well set, relatively authentically, and staged.

Others did not appear to come from budget issues. Longstreet's divisions were not in the Virginia mountains in 1862. Calvary very rarely fought on their mounts, especially Union calvary in 1862. The only strong man on the farm enlists and leaves for the Confederate army right before the harvest. Many Confederate soldiers came home just for harvest time. None would have left the farm just before the harvest leaving his elderly father and sister to pull the harvest alone. There was no compelling reason to enlist just then. Lee was on the move south toward Fredricksburg having been spanked a bit at Antietam in September - with Longstreet. They did not move through the Virginia mountains to get there. This setting had to be middle to late October, the leaves on the trees in Virginia had turned to their autumn colors. A girl finds her brother's name on some clothing he had left when he returned to the farm to store it before going off to spy, and she runs her hand over it as if she is in awe of the script instead of registering some anger, since we had just learned, the only thing keeping her from going to Baltimore and personal safety was waiting for her brother to return. She just realized he had returned and had not even spoken to her before leaving again. Of course, if she goes to Baltimore, she can't enlist as the story progresses. So, I don't quarrel with the outcome there, just with the means to arriving at it.

There were some others similar to that, some not so similar, but my intention isn't to run Ms. Hamilton's work into the ground. This one never took flight and I am hopeful her projects, as she continues to grow, do.