Reviews & Ratings for
Stories of Lost Souls More at IMDbPro »

26 out of 51 people found the following review useful:
Why, 18 March 2006

Author: jacksonfire7 from United States

The acting and directing were great, but most of the stories themselves were boring, uncomfortable, and pointless (a bad combination). I think I wouldn't have been disappointed with the film if the synopsis on the DVD, instead of saying "hard hitting" would say "attempts to be hard hitting".

The exceptions were "A Whole New Day" (Gandolfini), and "New Year's Day" (Knightley) which were both entertaining. A gave "New Year's Day" a 7 below because it was the only one that made me laugh. Since these are separate stories I'll rank them independently.

6 for "A Whole New Day"; 4 for "Euston Road"; 7 for "New Year's Eve"; 5 for "Standing Room Only"; 5.5 for "Bangers"; it is very boring and uncomfortable but gave me some insight; 4 for "Sniper 470"

Short cuts, 11 June 2008

Author: jotix100 from New York

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

An interesting concept, presenting several shorts to make a full length feature. The tone of most of the vignettes is an ironic one. Viewed as a whole, the stories go from interesting to just OK.

"Bangers", directed by Andrew Upton, shows a woman going into insanity. Cate Blanchett is amazing in giving life to this "lost soul". Even though it is one of the shortest stories, it is one of the ones that really make an impact.

"A Whole New Day", by William Garcia, is priceless. A man awakes on the floor of an empty apartment. He and his wife have a tempestuous relationship. His only way of communication is his cell phone. He uses to call his wife, who is an unhappy woman, made even sorer by his disappearance. When a young woman comes to check the empty apartment, that she evidently wants to rent, the man goes ballistic. How dares she to even think about it. The last scene reveals the secret. James Gandolfini is perfect as the loud mouth.

"Standing Room Only" makes a lot of sense. A few hopefuls decide to come early to claim their places in the back of the theater to see the hit play. There are only eight possible fortunate people admitted. An old lady with her dog makes an appearance to stand in line. She would be the last one to be admitted, but little does she know the others will ask for the eight tickets available. At the end of the performance, as the cast comes out of the stage door, a revelation occurs. Michael Gambon, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Hugh Jackman, Joanna Lumley, are seen in this fun story directed by Deborra-Lee Furness, who is Mrs. Jackman in real life.

There is another story about a supermarket that is not given credit by IMDb. In it, Ileana Douglas, Daryl Hannah and Jeff Goldblum, among others are brought together. This one was the weakest story since it relies on name dropping and inside jokes.

Col Spector's "New Year's Eve" was perhaps the longest of the stories. It shows the guests of a party at a private home in London. Kira Knightly is at the center of the story as a precocious young woman interested in talking to an older guest.

Tom Stappard's "Euston Road" about a con man has its moments. Paul Bethany makes the best out of his character.

1 out of 3 people found the following review useful:
Don't bother, 2 July 2009

Author: kimdino-1 from United Kingdom

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

"Supermarket" is a waste of time. I think it's supposed to be a comedy but the hopeful/has-been meeting a real star just falls flat with little else left. The slapstick routine with an incompetent trolley girl would have been better left out altogether. Good editing would have left this at less than two minutes and it still would have been dead. (0 points)

"New years eve" is, I suppose, a good example of a shaggy dog story. Pointless and doesn't go anywhere. (0 points)

"Bangers" works as an illustration of mental illness but is still fairly weak. This is where I started to award points. (5 points)

"A whole new day" falls flat almost from the start as it's based on such a ridiculous premise (she took everything, even the paint off the walls?) Though there is a slight element of entertainment value. (4 points)

"Euston Rd" has some merit. I could almost believe that this was done as a five minute short and the rest was added as padding to attempt to make a feature length. (7 points)

"Standing room only" is just plain silliness at work. Though there are plenty of bits to elicit a chuckle. (5 points)

"The same" is just plain sick. Freaks are only allowed to look at other freaks, what sick mind allowed this in here? I gave a massive point deduction for this one.

"Sniper 470" was not on my disc. I found it by googling and watched it online. Why was it removed as this was definitely the strongest item.

If you are planning to see "Stories of Lost Souls" make sure you get a copy that contains "Sniper 470".

10 out of 24 people found the following review useful:
Pointless, 12 June 2005

Author: HMVincent from Berkeley, California

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

The stories are (1) "A Whole New Day" with James Gandolfini; (2) "Euston Road" with Paul Bettany; (3) "Standing Room Only" with Hugh Jackman, Michael Gambon, et al.; (4) "New Year's Eve" with Keira Knightley and other more interesting people; (5) "Sniper 470" with Billy Boyd; (6) "Bangers" with Cate Blanchett.

These are all made very well, but they are pointless. When each ends, you ask, "But what was that all ABOUT." I can see a case for "Sniper 470" and for "Bangers." In "A Whole New Day," Gandolfini's character wakes up with a hangover, in his own apartment that's been emptied of family, furniture, and decoration. His cell phone works, but he can't call his wife, because she, in their stuffed home with screaming kids, is calling around looking for him. The story looks like it will turn Twilight Zoney, but very soon we learn the boring reason for it all.

In "Euston Road," con man Bettany invites a gullible mark to make seven guesses as to why the con man has no money. The mark bites, the con man wins, the end.

"Standing Room Only" has no dialogue. You see people line up for a stage show, and one character gets in a snit because she can't get one of the last tickets. Later, after the show, the people who were in line meet up outside the backstage door, and take pictures of each other. A trick is revealed. You will know what the trick is long beforehand, because of the heaviness of heavy makeup.

In "New Year's Eve," a shallow man gets a comeuppance. However, others deserving the same are not touched.

"Sniper 470" is a long piece, or at least it feels long, with Billy Boyd as the title character and no one else is in view. He is a sniper in space during an interplanetary conflict, and most of the short shows what he does during his actionless days in weightless space. The boredom leads nicely into a terrifying (for him) ending.

"Bangers" shows a Cate Blanchett's character preparing bangers and mash for herself and her mother, all the while talking to the cat and showing that she is coming apart at the seams. I would give Ms. Blanchett an award for this one - she is utterly convincing.

Add another review

Related Links