Critic Reviews



Based on 6 critic reviews provided by Metacritic.com
The first half of Lover's film is surprisingly affecting...But the film comes apart in its second half, when James' flight triggers a long series of flashbacks to the brothers' childhood.
My Brother is brimming with would-be life lessons. But the movie goes in so many directions, and follows through on so few of them, that all it transmits is a vague glow. It's watered-down chicken soup for the soul.
The movie's strongest element is the chemistry between the reflective Mr. Kearse and Mr. Scott (who really has Down syndrome). Improving on its obvious antecedent in "Dominick and Eugene," their relationship feels real, not like a movie contrivance.
A heavy-handed redemption story.
Village Voice
Writer-director Anthony Lover takes such a kid-gloves approach to his handicapped co-star that he achieves the opposite of the intended effect: Every time Scott enters a scene, it's as if someone just told the entire cast "Whatever you do, don't say 'retard.' "
What it possesses in heart and goodwill, it sorely lacks in narrative skill and artistic depth.

More Critic Reviews

See all external reviews for My Brother (2006) »

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Reviews | User Ratings | External Reviews