IMDb > Sister (2004) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Sister More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 4 reviews in total 

5 out of 5 people found the following review useful:

Great short

8/10
Author: Scott (scott.m.hathaway@gmail.com) from Greensboro, N.C.
30 March 2005

This little beauty makes its way out of Wales perhaps, and is a concise short about a trip on a public bus through the country. Shot in beautiful 35mm, this short seems less of a short than a slice of real life. It contains all the properties of a real situation down to the overly stereotyped bus driver. Even the script is tight, as camera blends with narrative and the images of a typical bus ride through the country melds into a living breathing film. Characters are likable, confrontations are believable, and the scenery is gorgeous. Overall, this is a textbook example of short film-making.

I was lucky enough to see it as a part of the Open APPerture Short Film Festival in Boone, North Carolina and am quite happy to have found it here on the IMDb. To whomever the filmmakers are who made this film, thank you for your submission.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Interesting but the lack of help in understanding it will turn some viewers off

Author: bob the moo from United Kingdom
29 August 2005

As his sister waits at the bus stop, a young man hurtles down a hillside just in time to catch the bus to school – the only one in this area of rural Wales. However once on the bus he starts to get changed and ignore the bothering from his younger sister – but his problems only get worse as others get on the bus as well.

Opening with a scene that crashes our main character together with a lamb trying to walk for the first time we are left with the knowledge that this short has "something to say™" but will not say it in an easy to follow way. And for me this was the biggest problem – I just didn't get it. I understood the theme of the brother standing up for himself for the first time and perhaps this being connected with the death of his mother (hence the lamb's mother later in the film) but it was all delivered in such a manner that made it impossible to understand without doing a lot of guessing for yourself. There is nothing wrong with a film allowing viewers to do the work themselves but this one appeared to be character driven and letting us make up the characters for ourselves was a bit of an ask.

Outside of this it is worth seeing because it is convincing and quite naturally shot, with realistic characters (mostly) and good direction that makes good use of the limited location. A little bit more detail, a little bit more development and, at the risk of making myself look like a fool (too late), a little more help in understanding would have been useful. Worth seeing because others have gushed about it, but I thought it needed more substance and a little less "deep meaning".

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Another Depressing Short

6/10
Author: Theo Robertson from Isle Of Bute, Scotland
24 August 2005

One thing I've noticed about a lot of short films that I've recently seen ( And now that BIG BROTHER has finished its run on channel 4 while BBC 2 has scheduled a season of shorts we're spoiled rotten for screenings of short films at the moment ) is how many of them hit home as to what a bunch of violent thugs we have living in this country

Take SISTER for example . An Asiatic lad sits on the school bus with his sister and to escape her nagging he decides to sit up the back . Bad decision because as the bus continues on its run a couple of bullies get on and is often the case group dynamics take over when they spot someone different to themselves

Despite being well made and despite the upbeat ending this is yet another depressing short film made in Britain , mainly down to it being a slice of real life . Can't anyone get funding for a cheerful short in this country anymore ? I should also point out that having a Welsh cast makes it very difficult when the characters in general and the two neanderthals in particular are very difficult to understand when they open their mouths

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 4 people found the following review useful:

A truly exceptional short film!

10/10
Author: iain-laughland2 from United Kingdom
30 July 2005

A truly exceptional short film! Subtle, powerful, and masterfully handled. Disturbingly real and stark performances from all of the teenage cast. Well worth staying up late to catch on a BBC 'best of' shorts collection. Bleak beautiful mountainous landscapes contrast sharply with the children's aggressive manner. An outsider (a boy of Chinese decent) has his routine disrupted when he sits further back in the school bus to avoid his step sister's nagging. From there things start to disintegrate for the boy as he enters a world of latent sexual energy. In the end it's the relationship with his sister…. Well that would be telling. More from this director please!

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Awards Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history