12 out of 12 people found the following review useful:
A masterpiece of its time.
David Kelsey from Middlesbrough, England
6 November 2004
This film is much better than the quaint oddity which one might expect.
Directorially it is a masterpiece of economical story-telling. In its
12 minutes there are only 28 scenes, each of which is a single
continuous take. In 27 of them the camera is static - no zooms, no
tracking shots, no cuts to close-up, etc. In only one scene does the
camera pan, and that is to follow the charging cavalry. The shot is
made all the more effective by the absence of camera movement
More than half a century before the Tony Richardson 1968 film, the
writer of this version came up with the idea of establishing a cosy
domestic relationship between Captains Nolan and Morris at home in
Britain before their Crimean service. This is not an obvious idea, and
is not based on any contemporary account. One wonders if Richardson saw
this film before making his own.
The action sequences are lavishly staged. It is said that 800 troopers
of the US Cavalry took part, and there are scenes in which that many
appear to be engaged at once.
The film is available as an extra on the DVD of the British Film
Institute edition of the 1968 movie. The visual quality of the film is
very good for its age - an excellent job of restoration. It is
scratched, but not at all faded.
Add another review