Magic Moments: The Best of 50's Pop (2004 TV Special) User Reviews

Magic Moments ***

[edwagreen · 8/10 · 26 September 2010]

Where was the recently departed Eddie Fisher in this beautiful nostalgic show? We immediately saw Perry and others, but the omission of Eddie was ridiculous

Thanks for reminding me that the 4 Aces had two hit songs winning the Oscars for best songs of 1954 and 1955.-Three Coins in the Fountain and Love is A Many Splendored Thing?

We should have also seen Tony Bennett performing, other than just a picture of him.

The show was made in memory of Rosemary Clooney and it was nice seeing brother Nick as a host.

Pat Boone was finally starting to show his age and Dr. Joyce Brothers showed why she has a Ph.D in psychology with her terrific answer of nostalgia. Of course, the good doctor is aging and that was 6 years ago.

The tunes were great and it was wonderful seeing the enthusiasm in the audience. That was a time when songs meant something.

Wonderful Nostalgia

[acottage-139-488491 · 10/10 · 24 June 2017]

These PBS specials are really SPECIAL.... love the music and love to put faces to each group...........we just watched it AGAIN today and I could still name the songs by the first couple notes when the band started...so good that these are on video or film and I hope someday the younger generations will sit and watch and listen.

Public TV & Pop Music's Crossover/Partnering-Is It Coincidence ?

[redryan64 · 10/10 · 25 March 2017]

IN WHAT CERTAINLY could be called "a sign of the times"; we find this peculiar teaming of the Public Television System and nostalgic collections of Pop Music from Eras long since gone. It would appear that the ever more crowded of the record companies' vaults as combined with the ascent of the generation known as "the Boomers" has provided the impetuous for what was,only a few years earlier, an impossible and oxymoronic alliance.

THE INSTITUTION WHICH we now know as Public TV had begun its life in the 1950's as Educational Television. The name still persists in some quarters and we well recall those early days of yesteryear. An inborn and innate sort of snobbishness permeated this new area of televising and it was by no means subtle or tolerant of other aspects of the industry; particularly of those stations, companies and networks which were so crass as to show entertainment productions which were sponsored by paying commercial interests.

THE EARLY, EMBROYOTIC Educational Television touted its commitment to what was perceived as being "High Class" and "Socially Redeeming" in content. Thus you'd be most likely to view Shakespeare, the Arts, Science (MR. WIZARD) and Classical Music. The system which would soon be rename and rededicated as the Public Television Service, had no place for such commonplace, low and vulgar an item as Pop Music. They wouldn't even give popular music the time of day.

BUT THAT WAS then and this is now. Over the years, certain heretofore lowly subjects and programming incrementally crept into the PBS schedule. Thus, items such as those represented by the likes of MONTY PYTHON'S FLYING CIRCUS, ANTIQUE ROAD SHOW and these T.J. Lubinsky Popular Music productions found their way onto Public Television's regular scheduling.

WITH REGARD TO this particular production, there is little with which we can find fault. The number of veteran performers, who have too long been absent from performing in public, is staggering. With a roster which features the McGuire Sisters, Pat Boone (Emcee), the Four Lads, the Diamonds, the Four Aces, Don Cherry, Gogi Grant, Patti Page, Rosemary Clooney (archive footage), the Chordettes and many others.

IF THERE IS any criticism to be leveled at the production it is that it has built in breaks that are strictly designed to solicit contributions from PBS viewers in return for CD's and DVD's of the program and other old favourite music.

THE PITCHES THAT viewers are subjected to are high pressure, shameless and persistent in their goal of raising fund$ for the local PBS affiliate. If we didn't know better, we'd swear that these were a sort of genre of the "commercial." But this could not be the case;for the PUBLIC/EDUCATIONAL television stations have long bragged that they were "commercial free."

WE MUST BEG to remind them that:"A Rose by any other name smells just as sweet!"

Everyone Is Dead

[juanruiz-65679 · 6/10 · 13 September 2020]

One more example of what PBS pulls out during its beg-a-thon, which has included Welk, big bands, doo wop, Mo Town, 50s, 60s, and whatever. One has to hand it to PBS to judge what demographic has the deep pockets. They seem to know the Welk and the big band crowd are all dead. Now they focus on on the those who remember folk, rock, and everything from their youth. In 20 years, it'll be the few with enough bucks to pay for hip hop and rap.

Problem is, everyone from these 20 year-old shows is dead. That they still hit you up for bucks doesn't seem to matter. If this and others were based on the music, the rating would be a 10. If based on the mercenary PBS, which is selling products in return for cash, it would be a 0. So I will give it a 6. And when the next generation gets stung for "the music of their life," they can pay.