IMDb > WWE Judgment Day (2004) (TV) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
WWE Judgment Day (TV) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 5 reviews in total 

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Judgment Day 2004

4/10
Author: wrestlingsitewebmaster from England
10 July 2005

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

By god, just like The Great American Bash 2 months later, this sucked.

Match 1 saw Rey Mysterio and RVD taking on The Dudley Boyz in a good match. Although I can't help thinking that RVD should not be in the first match of a PPV. The next match saw Torrie Wilson defeating Dawn Marie. This was crap, and the feud is still going on now! and as I am writing this, it's July 2005! Then Mordecai takes on Scotty 2 Hotty in a crap match. Mordecai sucks, and Scotty isn't far behind him. Next up two waste of space wrestlers Hardcore Holly and Billy Gunn take on Rico and Charlie Haas in a comical match, but no one cared. Haas and Rico win.

Then Chavo Guerrero tried to defeat Jacqueline for the Cruiswerweight title! No not Akio, Shannon Moore or Paul London not even Funaki but Jacqueline! No one cared, and I bet yer Spanky was glad when he left when he did! Next up one of the worst technical wrestlers on the roster John Cena takes on Rene Dupree in a crap match. This was the same for Taker vs Booker T just forgettable. Booker sucks as a heel.

Then JBL took on WWE champion Eddie Guerrero in a fair match. One interesting note is that Bradshaw decked Eddie with a chair shot and he poured blood everywhere. Backstage Eddie lost so much blood that he went into shock and had to be rushed to hospital. JBL wins by DQ.

Not good!

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Mediocre

5/10
Author: davidpenzer from gothenburg
16 June 2004

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Compared to Backlash last month, SmackDown's Judgment Day looks like crap. Well without comparing it, it still looks pretty weak. A mediocre event with few highlights.

Match 1: Rey Mysterio & Rob Van Dam vs. The Dudley Boys.

- RVD has been one of the most popular WWE wrestlers for years, but WWE keeps using him in opening matches. Rey and RVD are fun to watch, solid match to open the show. The faces win after a Five Star Frogsplash from RVD.

Match Rating: 3/5

Booker T is interviewed backstage. He sucks as a heel.

Kurt Angle comes out in a wheelchair and trashes Los Angeles for some cheap heat. Then he decides that Torrie will be fired if she loses against Dawn Marie tonight. Oh no... will the great career of Torrie Wilson come to an end?

Match 2: Torrie vs. Dawn Marie

- My God Dawn is hot! But the match is not. Biggest pop of the night comes when Dawn loses her pants and her ass is fully exposed for about one minute! Sometimes you just have to love WWE. Thankfully The Pervert (aka Jerry Lawler) isn't announcing. Torrie wins (if anyone cares).

Match Rating: 1/5

Bradshaw interview. Funny as hell. One of the best heel speeches in a long time.

Match 3: Scotty 2 Hotty vs. Mordecai.

- Very short debut of Mordecai. His music and clothes have much in common with Undertaker's. He don't get much time but he seems to have potential. Thank God he sells Scotty's offense, we've had enough of no-selling monsters. Mordecai wins via a Crucifix bomb, also known as the Outsiders Edge. Is it that difficult to come up with new finishers?

Match Rating 2/5

Match 4: Haas & Rico vs. Gunn & Holly. WWE Tag Team Championship.

- They don't have much time to wrestle because of all the gay references. Still I enjoy this match. Rico is entertaining and Gunn and Holly work much better in tag teams. Highlight: A nice dropkick from Holly. Holly later goes for the Alabama slam on Haas but Rico gives him a superkick. Haas counters and gets the pinfall. A good tag team match, we don't see that too often.

Match Rating: 3/5

Undertaker and Paul Bearer backstage. Bearer sounds weird as usual. Nostalgic moments here.

Match 5: Chavo vs. Jacqueline. Cruiserweight Championship.

- Jacqueline is a hottie, can't believe she's past 40. Chavo wrestles with one hand tied behind his back, so the hopes for a good match went out the window. If there ever was any. Jacqueline has the advantage, but Chavo Sr unties Chavo when the referee is distracted (really unexpected...) and Chavo then destroys Jacqueline with both hands free. Charles Robinson was distracted for about one minute, I think he missed half of the match. Why not just disqualify Chavo?

Good work, WWE, you have successfully buried what was left of the Cruiserweight Title. To give the belt to a woman (who should be on Raw instead), to have screwjob endings in each match and to focus on story lines over actual matches proves the fact that WWE cares absolutely nothing about cruiserweight wrestling. Fans want spectacular high-flying moves dammit, not this sh*t. What is wrong with Vince McMahon and this awful booking? Chavo regains the title, but this feud has made him look incredibly weak.

Match Rating: 1/5

A promo for WrestleMania 21 and then a VERY long and boring promo for the match between Cena and Dupree. Too bad I tuned in for wrestling and not promos.

Match 6: Dupree vs. Cena. US Championship.

- Cena continues to kiss the asses of the fans with his lame rhymes. In my opinion he has got stale as a face already. The match is a little slow, like it never really gets underway. Dupree shows some nice moves, but in the end Cena pins him after an F-U. OK match, but the finish was good. I was hoping for Dupree to win though.

Match Rating: 3/5

We look at some more promos. Too bad I tuned in for wrestling and not promos!

Match 7: Undertaker vs. Booker T

- Michael Cole: 'It is often debated, the question of whether The Undertaker is alive or dead'. Oh c'mon Cole, get back to the real world... Usual Undertaker stuff here. Great entrance, some no-selling, Tombstone piledriver and a clean victory. Booker is never even close. He deserves much better than this, no matter how popular Undertaker is. Match was not really good, not really bad, just average.

Match Rating: 2/5

We take ANOTHER look at promos. This time for the Eddie and Bradshaw match. Let's have an entire p.p.v. with only promos. That would win the ratings for sure.

Match 8: Eddie vs. Bradshaw. WWE Championship

- Bradshaw impresses me. I thought he would be awful but he is actually descent. Instead it is the old title match clichés that ruin what could've been a good match. Bradshaw wins by DQ (what an awesome finish to a main event), but Eddie beats the crap out of him afterward. I don't know for how long though because I finally fell asleep...

Match Rating: 2/5

The Good: The Haas & Rico vs. Gunn & Holly match had some nice moments. The opener and the main event were watchable too. No awful matches.

The Bad: The whole event suffered from crappy booking. There is so much on Smackdown that annoys me: Booker's heel turn, Undertaker's lame gimmick, the weak tag and cruiserweight division, the amount of underused talent... I could go on forever. This was a weak p.p.v and I am kind with the rating here.

Judgment Day Rating: 2/5

Was the above review useful to you?

"Talent used very well" , But did not expect to see it this bad.

5/10
Author: nick_6100 from Melbourne, Australia
19 August 2010

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

I thought this SmackDown! Pay Per View was probably the best "Talent Used" one of the year for the SmackDown! brand. By that I mean they had good talent on the show.

1. Rob Van Dam and Rey Mysterio defeated. The Dudley Boyz in a excellent opening match on Judgement Day.

Rating: 6.6/10 ( C + )

Kurt Angle pops up from something and he says "If Torrie Wilson loses tonight then she will be FIRED!"

2. Torrie Wilson defeated. Dawn Marie in a match that was kind of good at times but both were just used for eye-candy.

Rating: 4/10 ( D - )

3. Mordecai defeated. Scotty 2 Hotty in is debut. Mordecai should have feuded with someone like Booker T or something, I hate Wrestlers like 270 pounds sqaushing Cruiserweights.

Rating: 4/10 ( D - )

4. Charlie Haas and Rico w/Miss Jackie defeated. Hardcore Holly and Billy Gunn in a Comedy Match by Rico, Rico made me laugh so much. Haas and Rico retain the Tag Titles at Judgement Day.

Rating: 5/10 ( D )

5. Chavo Guerrero w/Chavo Classic defeated. Jaqueline to win the Cruiserweight Championship in an Intergender match. This match was pointless. After the match Chavo Sr. insults Jacqueline and kicks her in the tummy a few times.

Rating: 4/10 (D - )

6. John Cena defeated. Rene Dupree to retain the United States Championship in a very average match/

Rating: 5/10 ( D - )

7. The Undertaker w/Paul Bearer defeated. Booker T Was expected to be one of the best matches on the card, but yet failed again, even though the Talent was used well on this PPV.

Rating: 5/10 ( D -)

8. John "Bradshaw" Layfield defeated. Eddie Guerrero via Disqualification for the WWE Championship. I just have one word to describe this match: "Blood!" Lots of Blood was spilt in this match with Eddie taking his aggression out on Bradshaw.

Rating: 6/10 ( C )

Judgement Day 2004 Rating: 5 / 10 ( D )

The Talent was used great on this PPV but the matches lacked everything.

Was the above review useful to you?

I think that this Smackdown pay per view is good

7/10
Author: kliko400 from Australia
8 January 2007

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Now some people say that this pay per view was bad & it wasn't good but I reckon that this pay per view is good. Maybe even better than Smackdown's last pay per view No Way Out.

First match- Rob Van Dam & Rey Mysterio vs. Dudley Boys Great way to kick off Judgment Day, RVD & Mysterio are a very great tag team, this match itself was pretty good even though it was a tag team match. RVD & Mysterio get the win after a 619 from Mysterio followed by a 5 Star Frog Splash by RVD for a great win. 5/10 Second match- Torrie Wilson vs. Dawn Marie Before the match Smackdown General Manager comes out & announces that if Torrie Wilson lost this match, then she will be fired. Eventually though Torrie Wilson was able to get a roll-up on Dawn Marie for the win in a boring Diva match. 2/10 Third match- Mordecai vs. Scotty 2 Hotty Mordecai is a strong new wrestler who is making his debut here tonight. Too bad that this match is just a squash & Mordecai gets the easy win against Scotty 2 Hotty. 2/10 Fourth match- Hardcore Holly & Billy Gunn vs. Rico & Charlie Haas w/ Miss Jackie for the WWE Tag Team Championship.

Not bad for a tag match but Hardcore Holly & Billy Gunn should of won this one. But Rico & Charlie Haas get the hard fought victory to keep their titles. 4/10 Fifth match- Chavo Guerrero w/ Chavo Classic vs. Jacqueline for the WWE Cruiserweight Championship This match is just too ridiculous to add anything. Also Chavo Guerrero had to have his hands tied behind his back & he had to cheat to beat a girl. Chavo behind the referee unties his hands & nails the Gory Bomb on Jacqueline to win & also win back his WWE Cruiserweight title which he lost to Jacqueline previously on Smackdown. 2/10 Sixth match- John Cena vs. Rene Dupree for the WWE United States Championship Wow now I don't think I've ever seen a very long & great battle for the WWE United States Championship. Both Cena & Dupree have pulled out a very hard fought battle which Cena came out on top after an F-U on Dupree to retain his WWE United States Championship. 7/10 Seventh match- Undertaker vs. Booker T I was looking forward to this match, & it was actually good. Booker T tried almost everything to try & topple down the Undertaker but the Undertaker came out on top & defeated Booker T after a Tombstone for the victory. 6/10 Eight match- Eddie Guerrero vs. JBL for the WWE Championship This wasn't really a typical wrestling match. No, this was a brawl by both men who almost killed each other. Both men pounded away on each other as both men were busted open so badly that blood was pouring everywhere in the ring. Eventually JBL was able to defeat Eddie Guerrero by disqualification. Still Eddie Guerrero was able to keep his WWE Belt. 3/10 Not bad as Smackdown pay per views are just normally solid & are still pretty good.

Overall: Not bad as I will give it a 7/10 & a C

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Has its moments...but not enough of them

5/10
Author: gridoon
22 October 2005

In chronological order:

1) Rey Mysterio and Rob Van Dam vs. The Dudley Boyz. In terms of technique, probably the best match of the entire show! Rob Van Dam has some pretty impressive moves, and both he and Rey Mysterio are good with their legs. The "blind" referee is also pretty funny in this one. ***

2) Torrie Wilson vs. Dawn Marie. OK, this match is a little clumsy, but Torrie looks really great and both ladies apply at least one good hold each. **1/2

3) Scotty 2 Hotty vs. Mordecai. A brief and almost totally one-sided match. Mordecai has potential, but Scotty should change his name to Not-So-Hotty. *1/2

4) Rico and Charlie Haas vs. Hardcore Holly and Billy Gunn. HH is not bad, but this match offers little more than some lame "gay" antics courtesy of Rico. *

5) Jacqueline vs. Chavo Guerrero. A half-hearted attempt at a mixed match, with Chavo wrestling (initially) with one hand tied up behind his back. In my opinion, if they thought Jacqueline was up for a mixed match, they should have made it a regular one. If they thought she wasn't, they should have skipped it altogether. **

6) John Cena vs. Rene Dupree. The setup is too long, and the payoff is not worth it. A forgettable match. *1/2

7) The Undertaker vs. Booker T. The supposed "big event" of the night is a "big letdown". The introduction of The Undertaker is long and not very scary if you're over 3 years old, and in general this is one of those matches where the fakeness is just too obvious. *1/2

8) Eddie Guerrero vs. John Bradshaw. Those who prefer no-rules streetfighting over actual wrestling, will probably enjoy this surprisingly bloody battle. For the rest of us, there are some good ground holds, executed mostly by Bradshaw. **1/2

There is also A LOT of filler between the matches, but you should be used to that by now.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Official site Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history