Critic Reviews



Based on 15 critic reviews provided by Metacritic.com
Autumn is actually pretty damn good. It's a defiantly odd work, a movie-movie set more in the crime-film Paris of Jean-Pierre Melville or Jacques Becker or early Godard than in the real 21st century city.
Enamored of all things French and noir, American director Ra'up McGee has written a love letter to both.
The film is visually mannered and full of posing and longueurs. But it is stylish, very French (despite its American origins) and diverting if well short of brilliant.
New York Daily News
It's in French with French actors, but its film noir sensibilities have a filtered Hollywood vibe about them. In other words, it's pretty much a mess.
The Hollywood Reporter
Although reasonably compelling to watch and featuring fine performances from its charismatic and attractive lead performers, it ultimately displays little reason for being other than to serve as a transatlantic cinematic calling card.
The film looks great, but there's nothing under the high-gloss veneer.
Chicago Tribune
With its quick fades and creamy lighting, Autumn is all about looking good. McGee may well have strong films in him, but this one feels pretentious and gassy.
L.A. Weekly
Elegantly stylized but emotionally strained.
New York Post
Autumn wants to do for Jean-Pierre Melville what "Reservoir Dogs" did for Hong Kong cinema, but this new film is a joyless exercise in film appreciation.
For all the precision shooting, Autumn is a colossal misfire, a tedious film noir wannabe. It doesn't even qualify as film gris.

More Critic Reviews

See all external reviews for Automne (2004) »

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Reviews | User Ratings | External Reviews | Message Board