"Fremder Freund" is a German 100-minute movie from almost 15 years ago. The writer and director is Elmar Fischer (who also acts in here) and this is certainly among his more known works. It is the story of a friendship between two men who becomes stranger by the day when one of them, a Muslim, gets sucked deeper and deeper in the abyss of radical Islam. One of the most interesting aspects of the film is how power is depicted in the relationship. The Muslim is initially very shy and sensitive, but the longer the film goes and the friend the more boastful and violent he becomes. To add additional layers to the movie, Fischer included love relationships for the two male protagonists and this is where some female actresses come into play. I personally must say I have not heard of the two male actors here, but there are female cast members whose names are semi-popular here in Germany (Tander, Hörbiger). The thing I liked the least about this film is probably the parallel it makes to the events of 9/11. Yes this film came out two years after the terrorist attacks and with the Hamburg background, there is certainly some tension and need to elaborate, but it still felt a bit clumsy that the characters suspected him to be one of the terrorists. However, I liked the way in which they developed the plot afterward with another connection to terrorism (apart from 9/11) and that they did not go for a forced feel-good happy ending. This adds a lot of authenticity to the film in my opinion. I also liked most of the acting (especially by the non-Muslim friend) and the script has some good nuances and nice character development. It felt real watching the Muslim change for worse little by little and to see how it affects the world and people around him. Overall, this was a good film and I recommend it to everybody with an interest in the subject. I see some potential in Fischer here and I hope he can go beyond television productions at some point again. I think here he proves that he is up to the challenger.
2 Reviews
Splendid story of a friendship that evaporates just before 9/11
roland-10425 December 2005
This new film from Germany is the third to be released this autumn on the theme of Islamic fundamentalist terrorism, following the U.S. production, "The War Within," and the Dutch-Palestinian film, "Paradise Now." Each of these films is distinctive and noteworthy; as a group, they complement each other quite neatly.
All three films focus on a relationship between two men, who are close friends. In "War Within" they are lifelong chums from Pakistan who reunite in New Jersey, where one is settled, assimilated, and highly pro-American, while the other has been sent on a mission to blow up public places. In "Paradise Now" the friends are West Bank Palestinians who commit to becoming suicide bombers against Israel.
In "Friend" - the German title is better: it translates as The Foreign Friend - Chris (Antonio Wannek), a young Berliner, takes in a new apartment mate, Yunes (Navid Akhavan), a Yemeni national. Much of the film is an exploration of the deepening friendship these two share over about three years, leading up to 9/11. Using flashbacks and flash forwards, we follow this pair, sharing in the ups and downs of their love lives, parties, games, pranks, arguments and other happenings. Most noteworthy is the growing bond of affection between these two.
Beginning about 18 months before 9/11, Yunes starts to change. He joins a local study group of Islamists, grows a beard, begins to pray, and becomes prone to unpredictable mood swings mellow and fun loving one minute, as he was in the past, fiercely irritable the next, rejecting his old ways and treating his girlfriend Nora (Mavie Hörbiger) and Chris shabbily. At one point he goes to Pakistan for several weeks for some sort of special study program, but he seems, if anything, more his old self upon returning to Berlin.
And then, the day before 9/11, Yunes just up and disappears, leaving no word of explanation, no trace at all really. Chris, Nora and Chris's girlfriend Julia (Mina Tander) are perplexed. They search for him to no avail. Chris goes to the place where the Islamist group had met and finds a sign on the locked door announcing that the group has disbanded effective September 10, 2001.
Chris begins to think the unthinkable, that somehow Yunes's disappearance is linked to the terrorist events of 9/11 in the U.S., although Chris and the others find this almost impossible to accept. They are shocked, bewildered, almost unable to reconcile the lovable Yunes they knew with the the horrid events in America. After all, they attempt to rationalize, the German-based individuals already linked to 9/11 were in Hamburg, not Berlin. Still, Yunes never reemerges and the most extreme explanation inevitably seems to be the correct one.
Elmar Fischer makes a successful debut as director in this well controlled, very well acted, coherent story, which Fischer also co-wrote. The film works splendidly on two levels. It is an especially fine narrative about friendship. And at the same time, more in oblique strokes than the head on depictions of terrorists in "War Within" and "Paradise Now," we see Yunes's radicalization take place.
The film is an excellent showcase for its promising new director and several young, talented actors, including Faith Alas as Yunes's drug abusing sidekick, Raid. Mr. Akhavan, a native of Iran, is especially good. (In German) My rating 8.5/10 (A-). (Seen on 12/11/05). If you'd like to read more of my reviews, send me a message for directions to my websites.
All three films focus on a relationship between two men, who are close friends. In "War Within" they are lifelong chums from Pakistan who reunite in New Jersey, where one is settled, assimilated, and highly pro-American, while the other has been sent on a mission to blow up public places. In "Paradise Now" the friends are West Bank Palestinians who commit to becoming suicide bombers against Israel.
In "Friend" - the German title is better: it translates as The Foreign Friend - Chris (Antonio Wannek), a young Berliner, takes in a new apartment mate, Yunes (Navid Akhavan), a Yemeni national. Much of the film is an exploration of the deepening friendship these two share over about three years, leading up to 9/11. Using flashbacks and flash forwards, we follow this pair, sharing in the ups and downs of their love lives, parties, games, pranks, arguments and other happenings. Most noteworthy is the growing bond of affection between these two.
Beginning about 18 months before 9/11, Yunes starts to change. He joins a local study group of Islamists, grows a beard, begins to pray, and becomes prone to unpredictable mood swings mellow and fun loving one minute, as he was in the past, fiercely irritable the next, rejecting his old ways and treating his girlfriend Nora (Mavie Hörbiger) and Chris shabbily. At one point he goes to Pakistan for several weeks for some sort of special study program, but he seems, if anything, more his old self upon returning to Berlin.
And then, the day before 9/11, Yunes just up and disappears, leaving no word of explanation, no trace at all really. Chris, Nora and Chris's girlfriend Julia (Mina Tander) are perplexed. They search for him to no avail. Chris goes to the place where the Islamist group had met and finds a sign on the locked door announcing that the group has disbanded effective September 10, 2001.
Chris begins to think the unthinkable, that somehow Yunes's disappearance is linked to the terrorist events of 9/11 in the U.S., although Chris and the others find this almost impossible to accept. They are shocked, bewildered, almost unable to reconcile the lovable Yunes they knew with the the horrid events in America. After all, they attempt to rationalize, the German-based individuals already linked to 9/11 were in Hamburg, not Berlin. Still, Yunes never reemerges and the most extreme explanation inevitably seems to be the correct one.
Elmar Fischer makes a successful debut as director in this well controlled, very well acted, coherent story, which Fischer also co-wrote. The film works splendidly on two levels. It is an especially fine narrative about friendship. And at the same time, more in oblique strokes than the head on depictions of terrorists in "War Within" and "Paradise Now," we see Yunes's radicalization take place.
The film is an excellent showcase for its promising new director and several young, talented actors, including Faith Alas as Yunes's drug abusing sidekick, Raid. Mr. Akhavan, a native of Iran, is especially good. (In German) My rating 8.5/10 (A-). (Seen on 12/11/05). If you'd like to read more of my reviews, send me a message for directions to my websites.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
