Critic Reviews



Based on 18 critic reviews provided by
New York Post
Reyadas' radical rejection of filmmaking conventions is at first off-putting, but he's able to elicit remarkable performances from the cast of non-professionals while building tension that will hold viewers' attention. Love it or loathe it, you won't soon forget Battle in Heaven.
Simultaneously shocking and deeply religious, Carlos Reygadas' follow-up to his acclaimed 2002 debut, "Japon," tells the story of one man's battle for spiritual redemption through a series of explicit images rarely seen by even the most jaded art-house audiences.
Some audiences will find it an endurance test and Reygadas doesn't make it easy with his confrontational imagery, but he provokes emotions not often explored on screen.
With relentless and ruminative deliberateness, Reygadas shows us a Mexico City that seems to be decaying from the inside out.
New York Daily News
Reygadas is clearly out to shock us, to shake us and show us a host of furious ideas about class, gender, religion, nationality, love - really, there's very little he doesn't throw into this thickly ambiguous stew. If only he hadn't made his deliberately confusing, heavily symbolic story quite so difficult to digest.
There is an interesting set-up here for something great but Battle In Heaven never lives up to the expectations.
Austin Chronicle
This is really Reygadas' show all the way. And what he's delivered is a sad, tawdry picture in which all hope for salvation lies with God.
The Hollywood Reporter
Proves to be a disappointing turn-off. The film deliberately works against most cinematic expectations.
Entertainment Weekly
A notorious opinion divider last year at Cannes, Battle in Heaven is less about heaven or battle, or hell on earth, or the soul of Mexico, and all too much about gawking. And so, for all the ''shock'' of the movie's clinical carnality, this battle is lost.
A spectacular failure, despite further evidence of the director's keen eye and bold cinematic ideas.

More Critic Reviews

See all external reviews for Battle in Heaven (2005) »

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Reviews | User Ratings | External Reviews | Message Board