IMDb > La traviata (2002) (TV) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
La traviata (TV) More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

Mostly very good

8/10
Author: TheLittleSongbird from United Kingdom
18 July 2011

I adore La Traviata, always have done, always will do. This 2002 production is mostly very good, but I prefer the Zeffirelli film, the 1960s production with Anna Moffo and the 2006 production. I can't fault it visually, the sets and costumes are sumptuous as they should be, as is the videography. I can't fault the heartfelt story, the compelling characters or amazing music either, or the genteel playing of the orchestra or the accomplished conducting of Placido Domingo(yes THE Placido Domingo the tenor). Of the cast the most consistent is Renato Bruson, he acts Germont perfectly and his Ditta Alla Giuvine and Di Provenza are among the best renditions of the production. Scott Piper is a little strained at first, but he gets much better and it is a very, very nice voice and he is very dashing, against all that he didn't wow me as an actor. Stefania Bonfadelli is a decent enough Violetta if not great. She is a credible enough actress, looks lovely, can evidently sing and her Ditta Alla Giuvine with Bruson and Addio Del Passato are excellent. She disappoints however in Sempre Libera, the ornamentation and colouratura were for me a little laboured. All in all though, I did like it. 8/10 Bethany Cox

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Imagination and intimacy

9/10
Author: Gyran from Birmingham, England
30 August 2006

This production of La Traviata from Busseto made me want to visit its Teatro Verdi because it is everything that an opera house should be. It seems to be about the size of your local village scout hut and, in fact, seats only 350 people, giving a wonderful intimacy to the production. The set consists of just some steps, which serve for each of the four scenes. Everything else is done with a few net drapes, some lighting and a lot of imagination. Presumably, the opportunity to work in such an intimate setting was what attracted two of the biggest names in opera to Busseto, the director Franco Zeffirelli and, as conductor, Plácido Domingo.

More important than these two big names is the young and attractive cast that has been assembled for the production. This was my first acquaintance with Stephania Bonfadelli, who sings Violetta but subsequently I have seen her in Lucia di Lammermoor. These two performances suggest to me that she is one of the first great actress-singers of the 21st century. She gives good mad and she gives good consumptive. Right from the opening scene Bonfadelli is pale, hollow-eyed and doomed. She manages the first act vocal pyrotechnics magnificently and is also impressive in the more introspective music of the later acts. She is partnered by the dashing Scott Piper. It makes a refreshing change to find a young tenor who looks the part and also can sing. The part of Germont Pére is played by the veteran Renato Bruson who appears to be a great favourite with the Busseto audience. His Provencal song in the second act gets so much applause that he barely knows what to do with himself.

Zeffirelli's direction brings out nuances of the libretto that I have never noticed before, even though I have heard this opera many times. Zeffirelli also directed a scaled-down version of Aida for Busseto with Scott Piper as Ramades. Like this Traviata, it is well worth seeking-out.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Official site Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history