Critic Reviews

54

Metascore

Based on 12 critic reviews provided by Metacritic.com
75
Portland Oregonian
Never actively unfunny. The cast is far too smart for that. But it never quite pops like it would if it were whittled down to something just a little longer than an "SNL Digital Short."
70
The New York Times
The story is told in faux-documentary style, echoing the films of Christopher Guest, and if the cast never quite matches Mr. Guest's ensemble in comic inventiveness, they nonetheless manage to invest a very slight story line with a loose, scruffy charm.
63
Fueled by off-kilter characters, charming and funny -- if haltingly awkward -- dialogue, and a reasonable amount of thematic ingenuity, "Blackballed" succeeds as a modest tribute to the kind of aging boys club that idles for hours in somebody's parents' rumpus room, its members tossing around big-man talk but trapped in emotional adolescence.
60
Variety
The deliberately jittery hand-held lensing enhances the mockery in this mockumentary.
50
New York Daily News
Overlong at just 91 minutes, Brant Sersen's sardonic sports mockumentary would have made a hilarious short film. Instead, it's a mildly amusing feature that takes a few too many potshots at some very broad targets.
50
New York Post
Corddry leads a game cast, but the film is rough around the edges...It would play better as a TV sketch.
50
TV Guide
Though the performances are surprisingly good - the characters are drawn with a broad brush, but the actors, almost all professional comics, hit all the right notes - the material just isn't funny enough to justify the film's length.
50
The Globe and Mail (Toronto)
Fails to ever come alive as a human comedy in the manner of the best mockumentaries.
50
About as flat as a five day old soda.
50
In the end, Blackballed doesn't take home the winner's cup, but its genial stick-to-itiveness and reasonably well-aimed humor earn the film at least a good sportsmanship trophy.

More Critic Reviews

See all external reviews for Blackballed: The Bobby Dukes Story (2004) »

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Reviews | User Ratings | External Reviews | Message Board