2 out of 2 people found the following comment useful :- Excellent movie, 25 January 2005
Author:
squr from United States
The great Rishi Kapoor and Hema Malini star in this excellent movie. A
must watch, brilliant performances and a great story. The highlights:
Great performance by Rishi and Hema Great Story. Great Writer Great
Direction. Punjabi Background. The end has a lot of message about
women's rights. I watched it as it was written by Bedi and starred a
great cast. A must watch. The story starts with the background of elder
brother kulbhushan beating up Hema Malini all the time and the younger
brother rishi trying to save her bhabhi. One day the elder brother gets
killed and hell breaks loose. Rishi has to marry her bhabhi and
sacrifice his own love Poonam. He does not accept her as his wife until
the love and sacrifice of Hema convinces her one day and he conjugates
his marriage.
1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :- a widows dilemma, 5 October 2007
Author:
usman khawaja from United Kingdom
-it is notoriously tough to adapt a great book into a fabulous script
but for once this is fluidly established by a gifted script writer and
embellished with a truly dignified performance by the female lead-Hema
Malini who plays a widow who after her husband's gruesome murder is
obliged to marry his younger brother according to the religious
tradition.
the sensitive story is subtly executed with intelligence rather then
melodrama and the supporting cast is just as good ,yet the soul of the
movie lies in the pragmatic ,bereaving widow who has to take a tough
decision and that is where the strength of the story lies as she is
torn between the past and future but has to act to save her children's
present ,a classic book made into a sensitive drama that will haunt you
for a long time after it has ended ,the songs are kept to a minimal and
there are no clichés as in mainstream Bollywood movies ,i am sure the
Rajinder Singh Bedi will be very pleased with this marvellous
adaptation which does full justice to his literary classic.this is a
movie for people with a taste for the unusual and deserves a special
distinction by all criterion .a culturally correct setting enhances
it's authenticity as it portrays rural India with painstaking details
and the art direction and cinematography capture the picturesque fields
as fluidly as the subtle expressions on the faces of its ensemble cast
.a must see for the connoisseurs .ultimately it is a tribute to the
matriarchal spirit of the great Indian womanhood and a triumph for the
female -oriented intelligent cinema ,Rishi Kapoor brings a passive
frustration to the role of the younger man who has to accept the older
woman as his wife ,but the transformation is subtle and the quiet
acceptance by the children of their father's role by their uncle is
very tasteful yet truly heart-rending at times ,but this is a movie
which shows the ugly side of life which describes the truth of
compromises and the facts are rather bitter ,which might explain the
failure of this classic commercially in India . the controversial
nature of the religious tradition might be blamed but the fact it is
widely practised for the pragmatic side of the convenience to preserve
the familial structure cannot be denied . Poonam Dhillon played the
tragic girl who has to give up her first love as he is now bound to a
woman she had adored secretly as a mother figure ,the complexities here
are phenomenal but the director is gifted indeed and he is able to make
great cinema out of great literature . it is sad that this movie missed
out on tax exemption as well as national awards as no other work of art
is more deserving of those rewards then this gem cultural
representation which is almost revolutionary in concept and execution .
Own the rights?
Buy it at Amazon Rent it at blockbuster.comDiscuss in Boards More at IMDb Pro Add to My Movies Update Data
Quicklinks
Top Links
trailers and videosfull cast and crewtriviaofficial sitesmemorable quotesOverview
main detailscombined detailsfull cast and crewcompany creditstv scheduleAwards & Reviews
user commentsexternal reviewsnewsgroup reviewsawardsuser ratingsparents guiderecommendationsmessage boardPlot & Quotes
plot summaryplot synopsisplot keywordsAmazon.com summarymemorable quotesFun Stuff
triviagoofssoundtrack listingcrazy creditsalternate versionsmovie connectionsFAQOther Info
merchandising linksbox office/businessrelease datesfilming locationstechnical specslaserdisc detailsDVD detailsliterature listingsNewsDeskPromotional
taglines trailers and videos posters photo galleryExternal Links
showtimesofficial sitesmiscellaneousphotographssound clipsvideo clipsIMDb user comments for
Ek Chadar Maili Si (1986) More at IMDbPro »
2 out of 2 people found the following comment useful :-

Excellent movie, 25 January 2005
Author: squr from United States
The great Rishi Kapoor and Hema Malini star in this excellent movie. A must watch, brilliant performances and a great story. The highlights: Great performance by Rishi and Hema Great Story. Great Writer Great Direction. Punjabi Background. The end has a lot of message about women's rights. I watched it as it was written by Bedi and starred a great cast. A must watch. The story starts with the background of elder brother kulbhushan beating up Hema Malini all the time and the younger brother rishi trying to save her bhabhi. One day the elder brother gets killed and hell breaks loose. Rishi has to marry her bhabhi and sacrifice his own love Poonam. He does not accept her as his wife until the love and sacrifice of Hema convinces her one day and he conjugates his marriage.
1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-

a widows dilemma, 5 October 2007
Author: usman khawaja from United Kingdom
-it is notoriously tough to adapt a great book into a fabulous script but for once this is fluidly established by a gifted script writer and embellished with a truly dignified performance by the female lead-Hema Malini who plays a widow who after her husband's gruesome murder is obliged to marry his younger brother according to the religious tradition.
the sensitive story is subtly executed with intelligence rather then melodrama and the supporting cast is just as good ,yet the soul of the movie lies in the pragmatic ,bereaving widow who has to take a tough decision and that is where the strength of the story lies as she is torn between the past and future but has to act to save her children's present ,a classic book made into a sensitive drama that will haunt you for a long time after it has ended ,the songs are kept to a minimal and there are no clichés as in mainstream Bollywood movies ,i am sure the Rajinder Singh Bedi will be very pleased with this marvellous adaptation which does full justice to his literary classic.this is a movie for people with a taste for the unusual and deserves a special distinction by all criterion .a culturally correct setting enhances it's authenticity as it portrays rural India with painstaking details and the art direction and cinematography capture the picturesque fields as fluidly as the subtle expressions on the faces of its ensemble cast .a must see for the connoisseurs .ultimately it is a tribute to the matriarchal spirit of the great Indian womanhood and a triumph for the female -oriented intelligent cinema ,Rishi Kapoor brings a passive frustration to the role of the younger man who has to accept the older woman as his wife ,but the transformation is subtle and the quiet acceptance by the children of their father's role by their uncle is very tasteful yet truly heart-rending at times ,but this is a movie which shows the ugly side of life which describes the truth of compromises and the facts are rather bitter ,which might explain the failure of this classic commercially in India . the controversial nature of the religious tradition might be blamed but the fact it is widely practised for the pragmatic side of the convenience to preserve the familial structure cannot be denied . Poonam Dhillon played the tragic girl who has to give up her first love as he is now bound to a woman she had adored secretly as a mother figure ,the complexities here are phenomenal but the director is gifted indeed and he is able to make great cinema out of great literature . it is sad that this movie missed out on tax exemption as well as national awards as no other work of art is more deserving of those rewards then this gem cultural representation which is almost revolutionary in concept and execution .
Add another comment
Related Links