63 user 71 critic

Separate Lies (2005)

A couple's marriage is complicated by the introduction of a third party.



(based on the novel by "A Way Through the Wood"),

Watch Now

From $2.99 (SD) on Amazon Video

1 win & 5 nominations. See more awards »





Cast overview, first billed only:
James Manning
Anne Manning
John Warnaby ...
Sarah Tufnell
Christine Lohr ...
Alice O'Connell ...
Maggie's Daughter
Lord Rawston
Peregrine Kitchener-Fellowes ...
Bill's Son Charles
Henry Drake ...
Bill's Son Freddy
Inspector Marshall
Sabine Tourtellier ...
Philip Rham ...
French Lawyer

What You Missed at San Diego Comic-Con 2017

From the madness of the convention floor to the emotional panel reveals and star-studded interviews, catch up on all the unforgettable sights from Comic-Con.

Browse Our Guide to Comic-Con



A cyclist is killed, swiped by a Range Rover in a village lane. James and Anne Manning become involved because the victim is the husband of their cleaner, Maggie. James, a solicitor in the city, soon comes to suspect William Bule, a millionaire playboy who has moved back to the village. William, pressed by James, confesses to the hit and run. But the confession is clouded by Anne's admission of her affair with William. Written by johnno.r@xtra.co.nz

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Motion Picture Rating (MPAA)

Rated R for language including some sexual references | See all certifications »





Release Date:

18 November 2005 (UK)  »

Also Known As:

Laberinto de mentiras  »

Box Office

Opening Weekend:

$22,341 (USA) (16 September 2005)


$923,347 (USA) (16 December 2005)

Company Credits

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.85 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


Nigel Balchin's novel was first published in 1951, but was updated to the 21st century for this movie adaptation. See more »


James Manning: [to Anne] Why'd you tell people? They wouldn't have found out.
Priscilla: That's a Londoner talking.
See more »


References Jerry Springer (1991) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Excellent depiction of a relationship and its complexities
7 July 2008 | by (United States) – See all my reviews

Another great Tom Wilkinson performance punctuates "Separate Lies," a 2005 film also starring Emily Watson, Linda Bassett and Rupert Everett. Directed by Julian Fellowes, it's the story of a married couple, James and Ann Manning where the husband (Wilkinson) believes he and his wife (Watson) are happy together. An accident near their house on the night they have a party brings the police around. It is a hit and run that killed their maid Maggie's (Bassett) husband. James becomes suspicious of a neighbor, Bill Bule (Everett) when he sees some damage on his car. He confronts Bule, who admits he did it and promises to go to the police the next day. When James arrives home, Ann is angry that he is making such a big deal out of it and states that she was driving the car.

Of course, James then isn't so eager to rush to the police. She suggests that they call Bule and tell him their decision. "Oh, f___ Bule," James says. "Well, that's just it," Ann says. "I am f___ing Bule."

James' devastation is just the beginning in this well-crafted drama. Without giving the plot away, this is a good example of how gender switching changes a story. Example of what I mean: Susan Smith drives her car into a lake and her children drown. She gets life in prison. What if the father had done it? The chair.

You'd be surprised how often the outcome would be different. The same is true here - if it had been James having the affair and doing the subsequent activities, viewers might feel differently about the story. If Ann were in James' place, it would be shattering. As it is, it's tremendously sad.

Tom Wilkinson is heartbreaking as a man blindsided by the woman he adores, and Emily Watson does a beautiful job as Ann, who, once she frees herself from her lies - her involvement in the accident and the happy marriage - knows what she has to do. Rupert Everett as Bule is very effective - indolent, uppity and ultimately in need. Everyone here is very civilized in their dealings with one another, and no one is all good or all bad.

There are separate lies - James that his marriage is happy, Ann's as listed above - and there is one uniting lie - the accident, about which all parties keep quiet. It's enough for Ann that Maggie knows. In the end, all must deal with the separate lies that the single lie uncovered.

Brilliant film.

2 of 2 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: