Returning from his weekly (!) manicure and pedicure, Bernie mac's limousine faces a tricked traffic light. When he orders driver George trough, fake police arrests them. His back-talk even extends to challenging having been punk'd! The Yin brothers are despaired by a tricked studio swinging arm. Mischa Barton (The O.C.'s princess) complains about her friend's organizer being stolen in a restaurant. The suspect busboy is fired on the spot, then another employee (also fake) confesses. Meanwhile Ashton parodies nipple gate.
Big mouth Daddy Yankee is tricked into swearing 'on the air' during a radio interview, them told that carries a $463,000 fine or a performance ban. Sassy Playboy bunny Kelly Monaco's car isn't just towed away from a restaurant, but secretly switched and 'badly damaged', starting a war of words ending her back-talk. Sophia Bush's friend Snow spills wine over her in a restaurant, supposedly causing someone to break the lobster tank.
When David 'Angel' Boreanaz's wife Jaime pretends to have cut her lip on glass in a restaurant salad, he demonstrates how cool an angry gentleman holds on to the evidence and insists to inform the police. Kristin Cavalleri is the unwilling third party in a parked cars vandalism duel. Because Terrell Owens missed a ballgame Ashton counted on for his dream team, he's faced with a bus-load of seniors he must help getting up after a fake accident, yet is told he'll be sued for incompetently moving an injured.
Kristen Bell finds little boy Christopher's 'lost' dog Puppet, 'dad' claims without collar etc. it's not theirs and calls her in cahoots with teenage dog-snatchers, even informs the 'police'. Sassy artist Bam Margera finds himself escaped witness of a staged shop hold-up by 4 men to a police siege, which treats hims as suspect. Vegetarian Amber Valetta's brother Robert Parks-Valetta helps trick her to sit in a restaurant opposite a fat glutton who 'chokes' and reacts badly on her 'wrong' Heimlich.
Former Party of Five star Neve Campbell was hard to punk, so Ashton uses the highest cute factor: lost first grade soccer kids, supposedly picked up by the wrong truck. Brainless rapper Mike Jones's driver leaves his car, illegally parked. A biking boy 'accidentally' falls over it, so his pursuers can catch up, beat him and steal the bike. Mike runs, and the 'police' ask suspicious questions. That 70s colleague Danny Masterson won't stand by as stereo equipment fallen from a truck is stolen by another, but the owner only sees him and his mate carrying boxes.
Jealous actress Ellen Pompeo's friend -in cahoots- is 'seduced' by a restaurant waitress. Then he 'accidentally' tips $200. During a photo-shoot break snowboard champion Shaun White (19) is tempted to fly a remote control mini helicopter, which Punk'd controls to fall and explode so as to supposedly knock out the electricity in a whole bird sanctuary. 'Park ranger Phil' grills him.
Actor Justin Long is tricked to think his and his mates' under-age girls are drinking illegally. The restaurant 'manager' checks IDs, throws girls and waiter out. Then a dad attacks him. Musician Macy Gray is told her children music lesson studio has mold. Actor DJ Quall is blamed for 'ruining' a surprise party just by walking in.
With Christmas ahead, Ashton provides gifts for his victims, who still get punk'd. Sean Paul faces an abused 'blind' and gets blamed innocently after helping her look for her lost dog. Band 'Fall Out Boy', especially musician Pete Wentz, is tricked at a K-rock Christmas benefit with a derailing train knocking out Santaclaus, while everyone is in cahoots. Rap band Pretty Ricky's hotel room is completely raided by 'staff', which the 'manager' believes.