Ric Burns (brother of the famed documentarian Ken Burns) presents an exhaustive history of New York City from the settling of the area by the Dutch to the attack by terrorists nearly 400 ... See full summary »
David Ogden Stiers,
Mrs. Vincent Astor,
Beautifully produced documentaries with a moronically romanticized view of USA as the result of evil white people's transgressions against the peace-loving native Americans are a dime a dozen, but this takes the prize as the most idiotic. At one point, a native American interviewee rejects the 'charge' of the Indians being nomads with the words, "we weren't nomads - we knew where we were going" - as if nomads didn't. Another native American interviewee asserts that Indians lived together like one family before the white man came. Yeah, right. A highly dysfunctional family, then, straight out of Strindberg, killing each other at the drop of a feather - and who (although the Indians never claimed ownership of the land, as we are REPEATEDLY told in this film) lead bloody tribal wars that drove them to and fro across 60 million acres throughout thousands of years. Let's stop wailing, please, over people who simply lost to other people who were better at their own game.
For a more historically correct view of the west, I can recommend "The Great Indian Wars." It is downright hideously produced, drowsily narrated (although with occasional interviews that are very good), and on the whole a tacky TV production, strangely fussy about details - BUT: for historical accuracy and objectivity it is unmatched.
2 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?