A passenger plane vanishes out of the air, re-appearing several minutes later. Alva and Evie take Paul on their first investigation as a team as they look into the bizarre changes in all of the passengers and crew.
Two young children in Virgina stumble upon a Confederate soldier in the woods and believe he is a ghost. Paul and Alva go investigate some "ghost lights" in that area and get more than they bargained for. Time is a relative term.
Paul and Alva investigate a young Amish girl, Hannah, who seems to have stigmata yet there has no wounds. Hannah begins to have complete personality changes, turning into a disturbed young socialite from New York. All the clues point to a frightening conclusion that will result in the loss of one of the two girls trapped inside this Plain woman's body.
Paul begins having distracting visions of Tommy again so Evie and Alva take him to a TV psychic to see if he could help. Later, Paul is taking care of Matty and sees Tommy again. When the vision is over Matty is gone and Paul will make the ultimate sacrifice to try and find him.