User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Interesting & Historically Significant Footage
Snow Leopard29 August 2005
It's quite fortunate that this interesting footage has survived to preserve a glimpse of 'Goose' Tatum and other players from baseball's Negro Leagues, which at the time provided the best available opportunity for many talented players who had been excluded from the American and National Leagues by those leagues' notorious policy of segregation.

The footage consists of a series of short sequences edited together without any real story attached, and it seems possible that it may have been intended as a newsreel with an accompanying narration. Most of the sequences show Tatum and his teammates on the Indianapolis Clowns, in practice or other pre-game activities, with the players often making use of the opportunity to entertain onlookers. Tatum was quite an athlete, having also starred with the Harlem Globetrotters, and he had quite a sense of how to hold an audience's attention.

Indianapolis was somewhat atypical of the teams in the Negro Leagues, in that (at least in non-game situations) they often approached their work with a light spirit of entertainment. But there was nothing lightweight about their talent, nor of the talent on the teams they played against. (The scoreboard in the background shows that they are about to play the Kansas City Monarchs, who had some of the finest players of their era.)

Baseball fans who also love the history of their game often find the Negro League teams a tantalizing subject. More than enough survives to confirm that they were home to some of baseball's greatest players, yet the historical accounts and statistical records are frustratingly sketchy. Footage like this can't make up for everything missing, nor of course can it make up for the opportunities that these athletes were unfairly denied. But at least it preserves a living, moving look at some of the players who otherwise might only be names in a book.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great Look
Michael_Elliott2 March 2008
Negro Leagues Baseball (1946)

*** (out of 4)

Footage from a pre-game warm up between the Indianapolis Clowns and the Kansas City Monarchs in Cincinnati, OH. The documentary basically covers Reece "Goose" Tatum who was one of the better known players of the league. The Clowns and Tatum drew some heat for "clowning around" before ballgames and that's what is on display here. It's just a damn shame more footage of this league and its players isn't available.

You can view this short on the "Treasures" DVD, which has four discs worth of rare work from various directors including John Huston.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Impossible to rate...but fascinating.
planktonrules17 July 2011
This is one of fifty films from the DVD collection "Treasures From American Film Archives" and like most of the films, it's an ephemeral piece that would have otherwise been forgotten. It consists of players from the Negro Leagues warming up at Crosley Field (home of the Cincinnati Reds). Much of it features Reece Tatum and is reminsicent of a baseball version of the Harlem Globetrotters. This is NOT at all surprising, as Tatum actually played in both worlds--with the Negro Leagues during the summer and touring with the Globetrotters in the off-season. Who originally filmed this is uncertain but it was made in the 1940s before the Major Leagues were integrated.

Because of the sort of film this is, it's impossible to rate but also a very valuable piece of history as well as the black American experience--especially since such footage normally wouldn't have made it to theaters or been seen by anyone other than the person taking the footage in the first place as well as their friends and family.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed