IMDb > Chaplin's Goliath (1996) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Chaplin's Goliath More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 reviews in total 

10 out of 10 people found the following review useful:

An overall very insightful look into the life of a gifted comedian who passed away too soon

7/10
Author: SnorrSm1989 from Norway
24 December 2006

People who've seen Chaplin's most relevant short films (those he made from 1916 and forward, that is) recognize the heavy bully Eric Campbell once they see him, yet there's a remarkably small group who actually knows his name.

The documentary CHAPLIN'S GOLIATH is certainly a unique account for students of Chaplin's work, inasmuch as it describes the life of Campbell in a way no source has come close to do before. Chaplin hired lots of actors who eventually would make important impact, to large and small extent, on his movies. During the early years, most notable were Henry Bergman, Albert Austin and Leo White, and not to mention his leading lady Edna Purviance.

Still, Eric Campbell might have been the most important of them all, at least among the male members. One important factor was simply his heavy physical appearance, which did a superb contrast towards The Tramp's slenderness, and thus gave him the exact villainous character Chaplin sought. But besides being a remarkably high and strong man, Campbell was also a genuinely gifted performer who, through his grimaces and pantomime, could make the most dangerous burglars look like saints in comparison.

Campbell's exact date of birth is not fully clear, except that it must have taken place somewhere around 1880 in Scotland. At the age of twenty-one he married a pretty girl, who gave birth to a daughter in 1901. Campbell went along with the Fred Karno-troupe for several years until he settled down in New York during World War I. He eventually got in touch with Chaplin, whom he had known from the Karno-days, and was hired at his studio in early 1916. Campbell did his first Chaplin-movie appearance in the FLOORWALKER, a very successful two-reeler in which he played a cunning manager of a large department store. Cambell made a deep impression on Chaplin, and he continued to play similar roles in all of Chaplin's twelve Mutual-comedies with only one exception, a solo-short entitled ONE A.M.

CHAPLIN'S GOLIATH includes several very interesting interviews with the grand-daughter of Eric Campbell, Chaplin-biographer David Robinson and the grand-son of Chaplin's cameraman. It has been relatively hard to find since its original release in 1996, but is now included in Image's 90th Anniversary DVD-set of Chaplin's Mutual-comedies. If you're a silent comedy-buff, it is a must!

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Brief Documentary Highlights Chaplin's Mutual Cohort

7/10
Author: CitizenCaine from Las Vegas, Nevada
1 February 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Eric Campbell was Chaplin's nemesis in eleven of the twelve films Charles Chaplin made for Mutual in 1916 and 1917. This short documentary film traces Campbell's life from Dunoon, Scotland to the world's silent stage as Chaplin's chief villain in his films from this period. Campbell shook off typical expectations for young men of his background to become one of the recognizable film comedians of his time. He knew both Charles Chaplin and Stan Laurel in Fred Karno's musical hall acting troupe in England. He was an early portrayer of the "slow burn" and demonstrators of the difference in size as being humorous. Tragically, however, Campbell's life was filled with tragedy, and his young wife died followed by an auto accident with his daughter. Campbell then remarried quickly only to be divorced months later and die himself in a tragic auto accident. His granddaughter provides insight from letters of the period. In the end, the burial story of Campbell's remains serves as a timeless metaphor for all forgotten performers of the past. *** of 4 stars.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Good doc

7/10
Author: Cosmoeticadotcom (cosmoetica@gmail.com) from United States
9 September 2008

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

In the course of just the first few films with Chaplin, easily the biggest film star in the world, Eric Campbell himself became famous. Recall the scene where The Tramp literally gaslights Campbell in Easy Street? It's still one of the funniest and most memorable sequences in screen history. His thick, animalistic eyebrows, and patented slow burn, soon inspired imitators of himself (Oliver Hardy was one of them), just as Chaplin inspired imitators- one of them ironically being Stan Laurel, who knew Campbell and Chaplin from their days with Karno. So, flush with cash, Campbell brought his wife and daughter to Hollywood. Then, in an all too Hollywood fashion, disaster struck. Campbell's wife died suddenly, his daughter was in an accident, Campbell remarried a golddigger a month after his first wife's death, then divorced her two months later, and then himself died in an early morning drunken driving accident, in December of 1917. Chaplin never again had such a great on screen foe and partner, and never again was The Tramp so delightfully wicked, which led to the detractors of Chaplin's success and greatness arming themselves with his perceived flaws, and conveniently ignoring the brilliance of his anarchic Essanay and Mutual days.

The documentary does dig up many outtakes from Chaplin films, and the on screen and offscreen chemistry between the two men is palpable. There are many archival documents, from Campbell's childhood in Dunoon, Scotland (although his exact date of birth is unknown- anywhere from 1878-1885, and his full name was Alfred Eric Campbell) to Campbell's second wife's hilarious petition for divorce, claiming cruelty that includes exposure to hula dancing. There are the requisite experts, such as Campbell's daughter, and Chaplin expert David Robinson. But, the best thing about the film is nothing within the film, but simply that it exists.

The best thing about the prevalence of DVDs is that they provide an affordable way to preserve the history of the dominant art form of the Twentieth Century, and its oft-forgotten contributors- major and minor.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history