Following one of her visions, Raven and her friends find out that a scout from "Undercover Superstar"(an American Idol-type show) is looking for new talent at Bayside High School, and can't keep the story under wraps. Convinced that a new janitor is one of the scouts, Raven, Eddie, Chelsea, and other kids go out of their way to impress him, as Raven tries to dodge the wrath of an arrogant young hall monitor. Meanwhile Cory has to take piano lessons, but is pre-occupied with his parents old videotape as the musical duet "Toast & Jelly."
When Raven gives a boy with a rather poor sense of fashion a makeover, she has a vision that he falls in love with her. To prevent this from happening, she makes it clear that they will just be friends. The makeover becomes a greater success than anticipated and Raven falls in love with him.
Raven has a vision that she is going to share a kiss with Chelsea's crush. But when she actually meets the guy, she realizes that they share a lot more than that, and that keeping apart might be harder than she thought. To make matters worse, Raven's visions cause even more problems for Chelsea as she tries to plan a benefit concert at the school. Meanwhile, Cory and Cindy want to make their newly formed relationship official.